How To Make Pizza From Scratch!

1 / 2
There you have it: pizza from scratch.
2 / 2
A frosty glass of beer will make a fine complement to your homemade pizza.

A couple of years ago when she started to buy a
little teenie can of prepared pizza sauce in a
supermarket, Carolyn Allen of Barryton, Michigan was
floored by the tiny container’s giant price.

“So I decided to make pizza sauce from my own
homegrown produce during the following canning season,”
Carolyn now says. “It took a bit of experimenting to come
up with just the right amount of all the ingredients, but I finally hit upon a blend that the folks around here
seem to relish. The secret is the herbs: Don’t be afraid to
put more of ’em in than you think you should. That’s what
gives my sauce its hearty flavor and character.” Once she accomplished that, figuring out how to make pizza from scratch was pretty straightforward.

Carolyn Allen’s “Scratch” Pizza Sauce …

Mix 12 to 14 pounds of cored and skinned fresh or
home-canned tomatoes together with one pound (two cups) of
chopped celery, three cups of chopped onions, three chopped
green peppers, one or two finely chopped cloves of garlic,
and either one-quarter cup of Italian seasoning or two
tablespoons of oregano, one tablespoon of basil, and one
tablespoon of thyme. (If you like, you can also add one to
one and a half cups of finely diced summer squash. It won’t
change the taste but the squash will extend the sauce and
make it thicken more quickly.)

Simmer all these ingredients together over a low heat for
two to three hours, or until the mixture has cooked into a
thick, savory richness. Then cool the sauce, pour it into
one-pint freezing cartons (it should fill about eight of
them), and freeze .

…Just Naturally Goes With Co-Op Cheese …

“I also prepackage cheese and sausage for my homemade
pizzas,” Carolyn goes on. “We buy the cheese in six-pound
blocks from a food co-op, and I shred it with my salad maker
and stash it away in the freezer in one-pint cartons. When
we thaw it later and use it, it’s every bit as good as (but
far less expensive than) the costly little packets of
shredded cheese sold in the supermarkets.

“The same goes for the sausage. I buy it freshly ground and
seasoned—but with absolutely no unwanted
preservatives added—from a local butcher shop, and
freeze it (three-quarters of a pound per container) in pint

… And “Scratch” Pizza Crust!

“I like to prepare dough ahead for pizza crusts too,”
Carolyn says. “Whenever I bake loaves of whole wheat,
anadama, herb, or other breads, I just mix up a little
extra, package the dough in one pound lots, and freeze it
right alongside my other ingredients. Then when pizza
day rolls around, all I have to do is go to the
freezer and select one container of crust, one sauce, one
sausage, and one cheese; thaw everything; roll
out the dough and spread on the sauce, sausage, and cheese; bake my creation at 450°F for about 15 minutes or
until the cheese is slightly browned; and “serve ‘er
up’ to a hungry family of four.”

The Idea Works for Mother Too!

Well, that whole idea sounded so good when Carolyn Allen
described it that MOTHER EARTH NEWS’ recipe testers decided they’d
give it a try too. So they mixed, simmered, and froze a
batch of their own pizza sauce from summer vegetables,
grated some cheese, bought some fresh sausage from a
little country butcher shop, and worked up and froze a
batch of pizza dough.

Actually, our dough was essentially the Tassajara
Yeasted Bread—a big favorite around
here—featured in The Tassajara Bread Book (a 1970
Shambhala book by Edward Espe Brown).

Dissolve two packages of dry yeast in three cups of
lukewarm water (sprinkle some on your wrist to test its
temperature), and then stir in one-quarter cup of honey.
Next add four cups of whole wheat flour—or three cups
of whole wheat and one cup of unbleached flour—and
stir until you have a thick batter. Beat the mixture about
100 strokes with a spoon and set it aside to rise for an

At the end of the hour gently stir in one and one-quarter
tablespoons of salt and one-third cup of vegetable oil.
Then add three to four more cups of whole wheat flour (keep
adding until the dough sticks together in a sponge that
pulls away from the sides of the bowl), and knead the dough
on a floured surface. Use as much additional flour—up
to one or one and a half cups—as necessary to keep
the sponge from sticking while you knead it for 10 to 15
minutes (until the dough becomes smooth).

Place the sponge in a large oiled bowl, cover it with a
damp cloth, and let it rise in a warm place for about 50
minutes. Then, using your fist, gently punch it
down to slightly larger than it was an hour before, cover
the sponge again, and let it rise another 40 minutes.

Finally, shape the dough into two loaves, put one into a
greased bread pan, cover, let it rise for another 20
minutes (until the center of the loaf has risen up even
with the top of the pan). Bake at 350°F for about
an hour, or until the loaf is golden-brown all over
and sounds hollow when you tap it on the bottom. Turn the
bread out of its pan and let it cool awhile on a wire rack.

In the meantime, divide the other loaf in half and
freeze each piece in a pint container (for later use as the
crusts of two pizzas).

Ta Da! “Instant” All-Natural Pizza!

Then when—as Carolyn Allen says—”pizza day
rolls around” at your house, you can (as Ms. Allen and
MOTHER EARTH NEWS now do) pull a container of dough and one each of
sauce, grated cheese, and sausage out of your freezer.

Butter or oil your hands and the pizza pan (or cookie
sheet) you intend to use. Then place the lump of thawed
dough in the container’s center and gently flatten and
spread it with your fingers until it covers the pan as
smoothly as possible. (Don’t leave any holes or tears in
the dough, or the sauce will cook through and burn.) If you prefer a crispier crust, bake the bare dough a quick 5 to 10 minutes at 450°F
before you load it with the sauce, sausage, and cheese.

Next spread a thawed container of your homemade pizza sauce
smoothly and evenly over—but not quite all the way
out to the edges of—the dough (either prebaked or
unbaked). Then spread on the thawed sausage—fry it in
a skillet first, drain it, and then sprinkle it on if you
prefer less grease in your pizza—and grated cheese
(some folks like mozzarella, others swear by Colby, and
still others insist on Parmesan or a different favorite yet. Let your own taste buds decide).

Last but not least, slip your delectable creation into a
450°F oven and bake it for about 15 minutes, or until
the crust is a beautiful golden-brown and the cheese is
melted and bubbly.

This recipe feeds four. Or, maybe, on an autumn evening
when there’s a threat of winter in the air, it may only
feed two or three. In other words, fix plenty! Folks just
never seem to know when to stop eating this wholesome,
all-natural, do-it-yourself pizzal