Busting Herbal Myths: The Facts on 7 Herbal Remedies

These seven herbs have historically been used medicinally, but all have failed the scientific test of time: Chinese lantern, cinquefoil, dandelion, great burdock, hemp dogbane, sorrel and vervain.

| October/November 1999

  • 176-018-01-chinese_lantern
    Chinese lantern, also know as ground cherry, is commonly thought to act as a diuretic, but no scientific studies to date back up that assertion.
  • 176-018-01-fivefingers
    One herbal myth floating around is that cinquefoil reduces fever, but studies don't support such an indication.

  • 176-018-01-chinese_lantern
  • 176-018-01-fivefingers

Do these herbs actually treat the ailments for which they are commonly prescribed? We bust these herbal myths and show you the facts.

1. Chinese Lantern

Botanical name: Physalis alkekengi 

Other names: Bladder Cherry, Winter Cherry, Strawberry Tomato, Ground Cherry

Family: Nightshade

Description: A perennial plant with upright branched stems growing to approximately two feet. Its leaves are oval and pointed, usually two to three inches long. Whitish flowers appear from June to August and then drop off as the calyxes (lanterns) appear. The lantern contains a red cherrylike fruit.

Indications: Despite the fact that many herbalists suggest the use of Chinese lantern as a diuretic, there are no scientific studies to date that validate such beliefs. While no solid evidence exists for the herb's medicinal use, the fruit can be made into jams and jellies.

2. Cinquefoil

Botanical name: Potentilla reptaans 

Other names: Sunkfield, Five-Fingers, Five-Leaf

Family: Rose

Description: Cinquefoil is a creeping perennial whose runners can grow to five feet. It has toothed leaves with hairy veins and produces bright yellow flowers from May to August.

Indications: Common lore aside, there is no pharmacological evidence to suggest that decoctions of the plant root are effective as an antipyretic (fever reducer). However, tannins present throughout the plant suggest its use as an astringent would be effective.

3. Dandelion

Botanical name: Taraxacum officinale 

Other names: Lion's Tooth, Pissabed, Blow Ball, Priest's Crown, Telltime

Family: Composite

Description: The dandelion is a perennial herb with a slender hollow stalk that bears a single yellow flower. Its blooming season is March through September.

Indications: The use of dandelion potions to help with liver, gallbladder and other digestive ailments has no credible medical support. It is, however, an effective diuretic.

4. Great Burdock

Botanical name: Arctium lappa 

Other names: Cockle Buttons, Bur

Family: Composite

Description: A biennial growing to eight feet with large, wavy heart-shaped leaves and clusters of tubular purple flowers that bloom July to September. The small hooked burs that cling to passing animals contain the fruits, enabling the plant to spread over a large area.

Indications: While this plant has been employed for the treatment of numerous ailments, including leprosy, dandruff, rheumatism and lung disease, research has shown only one use to be valid: While it should never be taken internally, its properties make it effective as an external antiseptic.

5. Hemp Dogbane

Botanical name: Apocynum cannabinum 

Other names: American Hemp, Indian Physic, Bitterroot, Rheumatism Weed

Family: Dogbane

Description: This perennial is native to the United States and Canada and has branching stems growing three to five feet tall with oval to lance-shaped leaves in opposite pairs. It produces small white flowers from June to September. All parts of the plant produce a bitter, milky sap.

Indications: In the southern Appalachian mountains, the roots of this plant were either boiled in water or steeped in whiskey to be used as a physic for headaches and constipation. There is no scientific research that validates this use. Its only proven medical effect, namely that of cardiac stimulation, can be quite dangerous and so it should never be taken without consent and advice of a doctor.

6. Sorrel

Botanical name: Rumex acetosa 

Other names: Garden Sorrel, Greensauce, Soursuds

Family: Buckwheat

Description: A perennial growing two to three feet tall, with an erect stem branching at the top into several stalks bearing clusters of small reddish-brown to green flowers that bloom from June to September. Leaves are smooth and bright green, shaped like arrowheads, each on its own stalk.

Indications: Sorrel preparations have long been used as appetite stimulants, laxatives and fever reducers. Studies have in fact confirmed its laxative effect, as well as its efficacy as an external antiseptic. But research has also shown sorrel to have an excess of oxalic acid, which is poisonous to humans, so this herb should be avoided.

7. Vervain

Botanical name: Verbena officinalis 

Other names: Pigeon's Grass, Herb of the Cross

Family: Vervain

Description: Vervain is native to the Mediterranean, but is now widely naturalized in North America. It is a perennial herb with thin stiff stems and leaves in opposite pairs, the lower ones appearing oblong and coarsely toothed and the upper ones slender and lance-shaped. Small lilac flowers appear from June to October.

Indications: Like great burdock, many claims have been made for vervain, but nearly all have been debunked through research. Pharmacologists have found no evidence to support vervain's use as either an antispasmodic or contraceptive agent or as an effective treatment for fevers, skin infections or dysentery. Vervain's only proven uses are as a diuretic and a remedy for gout.

5/4/2013 1:26:45 PM

Ah just noticed that this was written by a Ph.D. That explains it. They have absoloutly NO training in herbal medicine unless they have persued it themselves. 

5/4/2013 1:24:00 PM

It's kind of ridiculous that you say you are debunking herbal myths when all that you have to debunk them is a lack of scientific studies. There is a lack of scientific studies on herbs because they are not profitable like pharma. These plants  have been used since the beginnings of time to help support healing processes. When one experiences the effects directly that plants can have on the healing process then there is no more denial. I do agree that some plants should be used with caution and can cause severe reactions in some people. Certainly no more than the massive amounts of bad reactions and deaths caused by pharma. Always best to consult an experienced herbalist! I expect more  from Mother Earth news. 



February 15-16, 2020
Belton, Texas

Join us in the Lone Star state to explore ways to save money and live efficiently. This two-day event includes hands-on workshops and a marketplace featuring the latest homesteading products.


Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 64% Off the Cover Price

50 Years of Money-Saving Tips!

Mother Earth NewsAt MOTHER EARTH NEWS for 50 years and counting, we are dedicated to conserving our planet's natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. You'll find tips for slashing heating bills, growing fresh, natural produce at home, and more. That's why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.95 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.95 for 6 issues.

Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
International Subscribers - Click Here
Canadian subscriptions: 1 year (includes postage & GST).

Facebook Pinterest Instagram YouTube Twitter flipboard

Free Product Information Classifieds Newsletters

click me