Avoiding Toxic Chemicals in Paint

Joe Hurst-Wajszczuk suggests you avoid toxic chemicals in paint by using low-VOC paints to lower your health risks and keep the environment clean when painting your home.

| October/November 2003

  • A variety of low-VOC paints.
    A variety of low-VOC paints.
  • It is important to avoid toxic chemicals in paint when painting your home.
    It is important to avoid toxic chemicals in paint when painting your home.
  • Create a safer environment for your family by using natural or low-VOC paints in your home.
    Create a safer environment for your family by using natural or low-VOC paints in your home.

  • A variety of low-VOC paints.
  • It is important to avoid toxic chemicals in paint when painting your home.
  • Create a safer environment for your family by using natural or low-VOC paints in your home.

Avoid toxic chemicals in paint by choosing safe paint for lower health risks.

I have to admit that I like the smell of fresh paint. Having lived in a collection of motley old apartments and homes, I loved the way a couple of gallons covered over the scuffs and stains left by the last tenants and created a "new" living space. To me, the aroma of freshly painted walls signified a clean start. But as it turns out, what my nose didn't know could have been hurting me.

That "new-paint smell" is caused by volatile organic compounds (VOCs), a class of chemicals that evaporate readily at room temperature. These toxic chemicals in paint are found in some pigments and also are added to alkyd oil and (to a lesser extent) latex paints to provide certain desirable working qualities, like spreadability, or to improve durability. Low-level exposure to these chemicals may cause temporary health problems, such as headaches, dizziness or nausea. Higher exposure levels, such as with auto spray booth operators, and longer exposure times can cause permanent damage to the kidneys, liver, and nervous or respiratory systems.

According to the Environmental Protection Agency, indoor air is three times more polluted than outdoor air. Outgassing from VOCs contributes greatly to indoor air pollution. Outside, VOC emissions react with other hydrocarbons, nitrogen oxides and sunlight to create smog.

To address some of these problems, more than 20 companies now manufacture low- and no-VOC paints that perform as well as their predecessors. A number of paint products can give your home a fresh start without compromising your health. Here's an overview of some low- and noVOC paints, and a few all-natural options you can choose from for both interior and exterior painting projects.

Stick With Latex Paint

Although it can be made up of hundreds of different chemicals, paint still can be divided into two subcategories according to its primary solvent. In latex paints, water is the primary solvent; in alkyds, it's a petroleum solvent (oil). Latex paints, with much lower levels of VOCs, beat alkyds hands-down for safety. (Even the newly formulated alkyd paints use much more solvent than standard latex paints, and cleaning up brush es, rollers and spills after painting with alkyds requires additional solvents—latex paints clean up with soap and water.)

The biggest difference you may notice is with drying time: Low- and no-VOC paints dry a lot faster, and you'll need to work quickly so that you're always painting into a wet edge (painting over dried paint will leave a striped appearance). Because these paints tend to dry faster on rollers and brushes, cleanup may take a little longer.

The Low-Down on Low-VOCs Paint

First, don't confuse "low-odor" with "lowVOC." Fumes from some VOCs can be masked to make a low-odor paint, which means that what you can't smell still can hurt you.

And don't assume that all low-VOC paints are created equal. A "low-VOC" label on a can means the paint meets the EPA's maximum VOC-emission standards: Latex paints must contain less than 250 grams per liter (gm/l) of VOCs; alkyds can contain up to 380 gm/l.

When shopping for a safer paint, start by reading the label. Look for paints that have VOC levels of 150 gm/l or lower. Realize that pigments, typically dissolved in chemical solvents, and other additives, such as mildewcides and conditioners, contribute to the relative toxicity of the final paint mix.

In addition to choosing a low-VOC paint, pay attention to everything else that's in the can. Because the EPA's regulations primarily focus on reducing air pollution, other toxic chemicals that do not increase air pollution, such as heavy metals, are excluded from VOC calculations.

Besides solvents, heavy metals and crystalline silica (beach sand) are added to paint for color or texture. These ingredients aren't a problem when suspended in liquid paint, but they are considered carcinogens if inhaled (which can occur when sanding or scraping). Ammonia is used to inhibit bacteria and mold, and to help the paint "flow" off the brush or roller. And although none of the major paint companies use lead or mercury anymore, paints with mildewcide additives still contain trace amounts of formaldehyde. Formaldehyde is a respiratory irritant and potential carcinogen.

For this reason, chemically sensitive individuals need to be especially careful about using kitchen and bath paints that contain extra mildewcides.

Request a Material Safety Data Sheet (MSDS) from the paint store to get information on everything that goes into the paint. If the store can't provide one, check the manufacturer's Web site or call their customer help line.

All Natural Paint Solutions

Vibrantly colored paints predate modern VOC-based paints by several centuries. The old painted walls of many buildings in Italy, Egypt and Greece attest to the fact that combinations of natural resins, oils, clays, and mineral or plant pigments can be both durable and lightfast. Today, companies such as Bioshield and Sinan have refined those ancient recipes to offer a no-VOC line of plant- and earth-based paints and finishes. (The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Company offers a casein, or milk, paint made from a mixture of lime, earth pigments and milk protein.) Because you mix them yourself, these products offer more artistic creativity. They can be applied full-strength for regular coverage, or thinned to produce a washed effect.

Because natural paints don't use the same solvents that give other paints smoothness and uniformity, they can be a little trickier to apply and tend to give walls a more handcrafted appearance. Natural paints are sometimes sold as a powder, or the pigment is sold separately from a liquid base, requiring you to do the mixing. In these cases, you'll want to make enough for one full coat: Exactly matching one batch to the next is nearly impossible.

Natural paints are not always compatible with other paint products. Milk paint works well on new wood and plaster, but can pull off old paint if it's not adhered well. Milk paints applied over latex binder (used in drywall joint compound) may "crackle." Some natural paints also waterspot easily. For walls or furniture that require extra protection, you may need to apply a topcoat of varnish or polyurethane, which means an extra step and the potential for additional chemical exposure.

Pick the Perfect Non-Toxic Paint

Here's a list of low- and no-VOC paint manufacturers. (Now all you need to do is find the perfect color for the master bedroom . . .)

No-VOC Natural Paints

Bioshield Paint

The Old Fashioned Milk Paint Co.

Sinan Co.

Low- AND No-VOC Latex Paints

American Formulating & Manufacturing Enterprises (Safecoat)*

Benjamin Moore & Co. (EcoSpec)

Chem-Safe Products*

ICI/Devoe Paint (Wonder-Pure)

Duron Paints (Genesis)

Frazee Paints (Envirokote)

lCl/Glidden (LifeMaster)

Kelly-Moore Paint Co. (Enviro-Cote)

Miller Paint Co. (Acro)

McCormick Paint (Natural Odor-Free)

PPG Architectural Finishes (Pure Performance)

Rodda (Horizon)*

Sherwin-Williams (Harmony)

*Sells low- or no-VOC exterior paint

6/11/2014 1:11:26 PM

I have had good luck with soy-based stain and sealer from http://www.ecosafetyproducts.com . I expected to see this company listed here.

6/11/2007 7:40:51 PM

You need to take a look at Ecological Paint, I have been doing research on the perfect non-voc paint product and from what I am reading, these folks have mastered both eco-friendly, without all the typical byproducts of an environmentally friendly paint product. I do wonder if you folks are capable of verifying the information on their site and checking the validity of the statements made. www.ecologicalpaint.com

3/16/2007 6:00:46 AM

I just read your article on paints and couldn't help but notice that you suggested that people should avoid cobalt in paints. As you stated this is a drying agent for paints and as far as I'm aware there is no (less harmful) alternative to cobalt that can achieve the same performance of drying. In fact I've studied a number of 'natural' paints which still contain this. If you know of an alternative that would allow for the exclusion of cobalt compounds then I would be very interested to hear of it. Many thanks in advance for your time, kind regards James Sumner



February 15-16, 2020
Belton, Texas

Join us in the Lone Star state to explore ways to save money and live efficiently. This two-day event includes hands-on workshops and a marketplace featuring the latest homesteading products.


Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 64% Off the Cover Price

50 Years of Money-Saving Tips!

Mother Earth NewsAt MOTHER EARTH NEWS for 50 years and counting, we are dedicated to conserving our planet's natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. You'll find tips for slashing heating bills, growing fresh, natural produce at home, and more. That's why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.95 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.95 for 6 issues.

Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
International Subscribers - Click Here
Canadian subscriptions: 1 year (includes postage & GST).

Facebook Pinterest Instagram YouTube Twitter flipboard

Free Product Information Classifieds Newsletters

click me