Seasonal Gardening: Almanac Planting, Tomato Transplant Yields and Fennel’s Beneficial Insects

By Greg And Pat Williams
Published on May 1, 1988
article image
ILLUSTRATION: CLAUDIA TANTILLO
Does science support lunar folklore?

The Seasons of the Garden column shares seasonal gardening information and tips with MOTHER EARTH NEWS readers.

Planting by the Moon

Every year, all the almanacs tout the best times to plant,
based on the moon’s phase and location in the sky. In
general, the guides say to sow aboveground-bearing crops
during the waxing moon and belowground-bearing crops during
the waning moon. The moon’s astrological sign is
supposed to make a difference, as well.

Does scientific research back such claims? Hard to say. In
L. Kolisko’s 1926-35 German trials, cabbage, lettuce,
beans, peas, tomatoes and cucumbers sown two days before
the full moon had better germination, more vigorous growth
and higher yields than ones planted two days before the new
moon. And after four years of work, Maria and Matthias Thun
concluded that radishes sown when the moon was in the
“earth” signs (Taurus, Virgo and Capricorn) showed the best
root development, those sown in the “water” signs (Pisces,
Scorpio and Cancer) had the most abundant leaf development,
and those sown in “air” and “fire” signs tended to bolt and
seed well.

Other researchers have come up empty-handed. A. Becker in
1937-38 found no significant differences in crops planted
on “favorable” days versus ones sown on “non-favorable”
days. And K. Mather and J. Newell sowed various fruits and
roots two days before each moon quarter and also found no
correlation between plant growth and moon phase.

Why the contradiction? The problem may come from the fact
that no research (that we know of) has correlated both moon
phase and moon position with plant growth, in accordance
with the claims of the almanacs. In short, the field seems
quite unsettled. Perhaps we can organize an amateur
experimental group to help settle the issue of “lunacy in
horticulture.” Feel free to write us and join in.

Online Store Logo
Need Help? Call 1-800-234-3368