The Best Guard Dog for Your Homestead

Find the best guard dog for your homestead with these training tips and advice on guard dog breeds.

| April/May 2006

Finding the best guard dog can be valuable in providing protection for your home and family. My home security system is large and black — and she pants when it’s hot and sheds hair every spring. In return for regular feeding, periodic veterinary care and grooming, I get a beloved companion pet that barks loudly when any strange vehicle enters my driveway. My dog also chases opossums from my deck and rabbits from my garden. But mostly, my watchdog makes me feel safe.

I am not operating under an illusion: According to the U.S. Department of Justice, 16 percent of American households were victims of property crime in 2003. Especially in rural areas, the theft pattern goes like this: Thieves make a quick visit to a house or farm to check for security, then return later to take what they want. But a barking dog often turns off potential burglars at the scouting phase.

It’s no surprise that, of the 68 million pet canines in the United States, most are expected to perform some kind of guard duty. Guard dogs look, listen and bark to sound the alert that something unusual is happening in their territory. After that, humans take over.

Dogs have performed this duty for thousands of years. In Tibet, the little Lhasa apso, called the “bark lion sentinel dog,” was bred to work as an indoor watchdog. In Belgium, schipperkes earned the nickname “little captain of the boat” because of their work as ship guard dogs.

“Dogs have coevolved with humans for at least 12,000 years,” says veterinarian Andrew Luescher, director of the Animal Behavior Clinic at Purdue University. "”Dogs are better than any other animal at reading human body language, and they are the only animals that can follow something when you point it out to them.”

Wayne Hunthausen, a veterinarian and co-author of the Handbook of Behavior Problems of the Dog and Cat, says most dogs — including mixed breeds — can be trained as good watchdogs. The exceptions are calm, less-reactive breeds such as bloodhounds or Newfoundland dogs.

1/8/2015 11:19:49 AM

The very best breed for protection in our opinion are German Shepherds. We've trained them to protect soldiers in Iraq and Afghanistan. Another good choice is the Belgian Malinois, however some lines of Malinois are not suitable for the inexperienced handler.

1/8/2015 11:11:49 AM

There is no better home security system than a well trained protection dog. A dog that only barks is better than nothing but a dog that will actually engage a burglar or home invader with it's teeth is far superior. These dogs, when properly trained, are excellent family companions and not undisciplined dogs that are to be feared by those around them daily.

6/21/2014 6:02:20 PM

My family love animals. We have a small zoo. Horses, alpacas, goats, cows, geese, chickens, etc. All free range except some of the horses and the cows. Currently 7 watch dogs. The golden retriever is very friendly but will bark and would not hurt a flea unless a child was threatened. The 4 English Shepherds (traditional American farm dog) have vastly different personalities but all are great watch dogs. All contribute to the farm security. The Lab Husky mix is the best at chasing airplanes away and is the first to notice birds of prey. The Swedish Vallhund is pretty much a wolf with short legs. Great little bark and a big heart. Plenty of predators. Wolf, coyote, fox, raccoons, weasel, bobcat, martins, fishers, rare cougar and lynx. Bear but I do not consider them high on the predator list unless it it's your garbage cans your worried about. Virtually nonexistent predator loss. Visitors often stay in their car until a family member calls off the security crew. Anyone casing the joint would have to consider a multitude of variables and I suspect would pick on a different target.

mother earth news fair


Feb. 17-18, 2018
Belton, Texas

More than 150 workshops, great deals from more than 200 exhibitors, off-stage demos, hands-on workshops, and great food!