My wife, Sherrie, and I first attempted to build raised garden beds as a rather desperate means of dealing with a garden site that offered only rocky, dead, chemically abused soil. There was little literature on the subject that we knew of, but we did remember reading that the Chinese have been planting in loosened mounds of earth for 40 centuries.
Much to our surprise and excitement, the beds of composted clay soil that we prepared and planted that spring soon produced an abundance of healthy and delicious vegetables. Visitors ran for their cameras as soon as they saw our attractive jungle. We wondered how we could have gardened for years without discovering that with a bit of effort we could have doubled, tripled and quadrupled our yields while halving, thirding and quartering our garden work.
We saw, too, that we no longer needed to buy or hire a plow, or drag a cultivator, a tiller or even a common hoe. To dig in raised garden beds, we needed only four tools: a fork, a rake, a shovel and a hand trowel — all inexpensive.
The Cautious Approach to Building Raised Garden Beds
If you're not ready to commit yourself to raised-bed gardening without some evidence that it works, try the following experiment: Mark out one or two plots in your garden (make them about 4-by-8 or 4-by-12 feet) and — using a four-tined garden fork or an iron bar — loosen the soil as deeply as you can drive in the tool. Once that is done, don't step on the loosened soil, or you'll undo some of the good that your hard work accomplished — namely, aerating soil to overcome the heavy compactness that discourages plant growth. The loosened soil's increased capacity to hold oxygen and water should result in plants that are noticeably bigger, healthier and more productive.
The worked beds will likely be a few inches higher than the surrounding compacted soil, but they may not be high enough to warrant borders of planks or logs. Then again, you might want to outline them anyway, if only to remind yourself to avoid stepping inside the beds.
Mulch these areas with compost, to add more nutrients and a bit more height. Then go ahead and plant intensively ... that is, sow the seeds just far enough apart so that when the plants are adult size, their leaves will just barely touch those of their neighbors. This will provide a shade mulch that helps to keep down weeds.
The Raised-Bed Quick Fix
We developed a shortcut route to raised-bed gardening when moving our homestead to new acreage one May. What with all the work of transferring our belongings, there wasn't time to spare for digging garden beds before planting. So we brought a couple of dumptruck loads of compost from our former home's huge pile and unloaded them at the new garden's location. Then we shoveled and raked the material into 24-foot-long mounds, lined them with lumber to keep the loam in place, and planted.
The new beds didn't have the depth of compost — and therefore the level of production — that our former plot had enjoyed, but the method did allow us to harvest yields larger and heavier than the conventionally grown gardens around us. When we have the time, we'll dig down and fill the bed with compost and organic materials as described later in this article, but the shortcut method for building raised garden beds has proven to be an effective way to get going on raised beds without a whole lot of work, and to quickly produce a more attractive, more productive and more easily cared for garden. (Even when using the quick fix method, it's a good idea to loosen compacted soil in the area where the bed is going to be built. As noted above, you can do this easily by pushing or driving an iron bar or four-tine fork into the top 10 or 12 inches of the soil and breaking it up.)
We learned a couple of lessons while preparing this (almost) instant garden, too. The first dump-truck load was simply dropped at the approximate site of the bed-to-be; we then had to shovel the soil into its proper place. That taught us two things:
- to position the lumber before bringing in the topsoil, and ...
- to take care that the truck puts the earth where we want it in the first place, thus minimizing the heavy handwork.
Build Raised Garden Beds With the Trench N' Mound Procedure
If your garden is in a well-drained location, beds can be created by digging the topsoil out of the pathway areas — say, to a depth of 6 to 10 inches — and adding it to the planting areas. [NOTE: This technique works very well in freshly rototilled plots.] This will double the depth of topsoil available to plant in, making good use of what otherwise would only be trod upon.
Finished compost can be mixed with the extra soil, if available. If not, you can simply sheet-compost by adding organic materials such as grass clippings, kitchen garbage, wood ashes, sawdust, leaves and rotted manure to the bed areas before covering them with the new earth. We're careful to hand-pick all rocks out of the bed so the plants' roots won't have those obstacles to deal with, and to remove any roots — especially grass roots — that are likely to continue growing and choke our crops. We find that every bit of care taken in preparing raised-bed soil pays off very handsomely. Once your soil is in good shape, you'll have eliminated a great many of the problems usually associated with gardening.
The Double-Digging Raised Bed Gardening System
For this method, mark out a rectangle — in a convenient spot in your row garden — that's 3- to 4-feet wide and 6- to 12-feet long. Now dig a 1-foot-deep trench across one end of this space and wheelbarrow the soil to the other end of the planned bed. (You'll later use this to fill the last trench you dig.) Now, again with an iron bar or four-tined fork, loosen the soil in the bottom of the trench as deeply as possible.
With that done, fill the pit with kitchen garbage, moldy hay, leaves, grass clippings, manure or anything else compostable. Then dig an adjacent trench to the same depth, mounding the removed topsoil on the organic material in the first trench. When you finish digging the second trench, plunge the iron bar or fork along the bottom to break up the subsoil.
Again, fill the second trench with organic material, dig another trench, and place the topsoil over the to-be-composted matter. Continue this process until the bed is completed. Cover the last compost-filled trench with the extra soil from the wheelbarrow, then line the bed with boards, rocks or logs, or simply leave it mounded.
The Deep-Bed Method (Deep-Compost Method)
When we learned that a tomato plant's roots will reach 5 feet into the earth if not blocked by hardpan, that lettuce roots can plunge as deep as 8 feet, and that beet roots may descend to 10 feet, we decided to dig our beds 2 feet deep, at least, and then pile the mound at least one foot above ground. That gives the roots a minimum of 3 feet in which they can easily reach the nutrients necessary to build healthy plants. It happens we had a backhoe on hand to do the digging with the first year. But knowing what we know now, we'd hire one if we had to. It's well worth the expense, considering the better food, the reduction in pest and disease problems and the enormous yields that result from the extra-deep beds.
After the beds are dug, we fill each 24-foot-long, 3-foot-wide plot with organic matter and allow it to slowly decompose over the months and years. Once filled, the beds are raked to prepare a seedbed. The mounds shouldn't be crowned (rounded over), as that can cause water runoff and erosion. Instead, flatten the top to hold the rainwater, smooth the surface carefully, and put in the seeds and seedlings.
Here — in detail — is how we fill the deep-compost trenches: On the bottom of the excavation we place approximately 6 inches of unshredded brush and prunings, which will trap air for the plants' roots for years to come. Covering that is half a foot (at least) of old hay and weeds that we've gathered and piled up for just this purposile. It doesn't matter if the material is dry or green, since it's being buried so deeply. Then a 6-inch layer of subsoil (all rocks removed) is added, to make sure all the trace elements are included, followed by 3 or more inches of manure. (We find it's OK to use the material fresh at this depth.) After every layer is applied, by the way, we add a sprinkling of rich topsoil and manure to help trigger bacterial action.
Next comes a 3-inch layer of a mixture of whatever we have an abundance of: leaves, kitchen garbage, grass clippings, wood ashes, pine needles, sawdust or just about anything organic. With this step completed, the bed is filled to ground level.
Then a 6-inch cover of wet, spoiled hay is applied, topped by a 3-inch layer of well-cooked compost and, finally, 3 inches of good topsoil to cover it all. The finished bed is ready to rake level on top and plant.
The Four-Season Raised Garden Bed
For six years now we've gardened right through the winter by covering our deep-compost beds with a foot of hay and a sheet of plastic. Normally, the added insulation that snow provides keeps frost from reaching the plants' roots during the December-to-March cold season here in upstate New York (USDA Zone 5). This past winter's unusual conditions upped the ante for local year-round gardeners, however. Usually there's pretty constant snow cover, and the temperature dips below zero only rarely. However, last year the ground was often bare, and the thermometer hovered between 20 and -20 degrees Fahrenheit day and night for much of December, freezing our 3-foot-deep water line on Christmas Day. While the garden beds (carrots, beets, turnips, cole crops, chard, spinach, etc.) were protected on top with a foot of hay, the frost froze the moist earth in the wide paths between the beds, attacking the roots from below.
We plan to avoid a recurrence of that problem by lining our new raised beds with plastic-foam insulation before filling them with the compost materials. Insulation that's 2 inches thick will provide sufficient protection, we think, even in USDA Zones 5 or above, if it extends at least 2 feet deep. If the temperature stays near zero for several days with bare-ground conditions, we'll also pile hay in the paths to hold back the frost.
The insulation could be used to cover the top of the beds, and may be no more expensive than hay or plastic in some areas where the former costs $8 or more per bale. The bed caps shown in the illustration in the Image Gallery are designed for short crops only. We'll continue using dry hay and plastic for members of the cabbage family.
I'm confident that anyone with a few square feet of garden space, no matter how poor the soil, can raise more than $2 worth of food on each of those square feet each year if they build raised garden beds similar to those described here. In fact, conventional gardeners would be well-advised to reduce their garden area when converting to the deep-compost method, unless they plan to feed the neighbors or start a roadside stand!