The Search for Rare, Heritage Apples

Reader Contribution by Tom Brown
article image

The past year was a rewarding
one for apple discovery, because I potentially found the apple that started my
apple search about sixteen years ago — the ‘Harper’s Seedling’ apple.

In the very early years of my
apple search I found an excellent apple in Wilkes County, N.C.
called a ‘Streaked June’ near the home of Sherrill Pardue. I grafted it and
planted a tree in my orchard.  Years
later when I checked back, the original tree had died. The apple name never
really made sense because this “June” apple ripened in late August.

Even though I might not
initially find an apple such as the ‘Harper’s Seedling’, I keep thinking about
it and continue to compare apples I encounter to the descriptions I have. This
year I had many well-colored ‘Streaked June’ apples; I realized that it fit the
description of my long-lost apple. I then took some of the apples and showed
them to the one remaining person who remembered the apple, Ricky Evans; he said
“Yes, it looks just like the ‘Harper’s Seedling.'”
Ideally, I would like to have
three identifications, but the apple discovery process is often a race against
time, and while I was looking for the apple, two people who remembered it
passed away and the memory of another has greatly dimmed. Other apples found
include the following: ‘Appalachian Limbertwig’ (probably), ‘August Beauty,’
‘Aunt Sally,’ ‘Big Boy,’ ‘Big Red,’ ‘Bitter Sweet,’ ‘Black Ammit,’ ‘Carter
County,’ ‘Cheese’ (England), ‘Corder,’ ‘Ell Star,’ ‘Ernest Blair Well’ Apple,
‘Fall Astor,’ ‘Fired,’ ‘Haycock,’ ‘High Top Sweet’ (green), ‘Lady Williams,’
‘Pitney,’ ‘Pumpkin Sweet’ (large, yellow), ‘Red Astor,’ ‘Rose Sweet,’ ‘Ruusin
Ball,’ ‘Striped Virginia Beauty,’ ‘Summer Sweet,’ ‘Summer Treat,’
‘Tendersweet,’ ‘Thinskin,’ ‘Vandever,’ and ‘Water Luscious.’
Pictured at right: Junior Johnson’s ‘Black Beauty’ heritage apple trees and cows.

My Favorite Place

The most wonderful place to
search for heritage apples is Wilkes
County, N.C. My apple
journey started with searching for the ‘Harper’s Seedling’ apple near my home
in western Forsyth County, N.C. I next spent extensive time about an
hour west in Iredell and Alexander
Counties, where I had my
first success in finding lost apple varieties. (I grew up in western Iredell
County.)  Many people had mentioned Wilkes County
apples, so I decided to investigate. Wilkes proved to be the true “mother load
of heritage apples” — the complete list of the 400 apples mentioned as having
been in Wilkes County is at the end of this post.

Wilkes County is
one of the larger counties in North Carolina,
located in the northern Piedmont region, at an elevation of 1,300 feet. The
County is a hilly basin with a surrounding crescent of mountains, the Blue
Ridge Mountains at the west and north and the Brushy Mountains to the south,
which is the location of several commercial apple orchards today. However, the
area had an incredibly larger apple production in the early 1900s — “hills
covered with apple trees.”

I initially approached the Wilkes Journal-Patriot to see if they
would do a newspaper article about my searching for old apples in Wilkes County.
They were kind enough to do so and I received over 20 responses. I later
realized that responses such as this, if followed up, gave me portals into the
community. The typical person who responded had an apple they wanted identified
or they remembered an old apple that they would like to find. One man who
contacted me, Hershel Green, said that he had a ‘Buckeye Beauty’ apple tree, an
apple variety once sold by a Tennessee
nursery in 1928. Finding a lost apple variety this easily is very rare.
Usually, I have to go through many successive people contacts before a special
apple emerges.

A Surprise at Shepherds

One of my early letters was
from Nellie & Mary Dimmette who lived in the Shepherds Crossroads
community. Nellie was an older apple grafter who had three or four apple trees.
One was a ‘Horse’ and another was an apple that I later identified as a ‘White
Top,’ plus a sweet apple which was originally given to the family by newly
released slaves.

To the casual observer, the
Shepherds Crossroads area would not have looked like a good place to search for
old apples; it was mostly open farm land with a few scattered apple trees.
Here, I fortunately met Ebert Billings. In any area, people contacts go more
fluidly if they can be made with a respected member of the community, and this
also greatly helped in Wilkes
County. Ebert was a
retired minister and he seemed to know people in every household for miles
around. Such assistance allowed me to quickly inquire about apple trees.
Ebert’s family did have some old apples themselves: ‘Queen,’ ‘Pound Pippin,’ ‘Springdale,’ etc.  With his help I found the following: ‘Sugar
Ball,’ ‘Pear’ (apple), ‘Yellow June,’ ‘Sour June,’ ‘Pike,’ ‘White Sweet,’
‘Ladonium,’ ‘Blood Red Crab,’ ‘Summer Cheese,’ ‘Winter Spice,’ ‘Horse,’ ‘White
Limbertwig,’ ‘May,’ ‘Burnskin,’ ‘Yellow Meat,’ and ‘Oat.’

House-to-House Search

Pictured at right; The ‘Black Beauty’ apple variety attributes its dark, black spots on the surface to Sooty
Blotch, a non-harmful visual imperfection caused by not spraying with a proper
fungicide. The splotches spread, causing the apple to turn black as it reaches maturity.

In Wilkes County,
I talked to anyone who would talk about old apples — even those who did not own
any apple trees because their apple memories were very valuable to record.  I made the Wilkes County
apple discovery process essentially a house-to-house search. On the 14.6-mile Longbottom Road, I

every single apple tree I could see from the road except three
where access was complicated. I also investigated many off-road apple sites. Wilkes County
is just an hour from my home so I frequently made multiple trips there a week.
It was such a rich old apple area that I was disappointed if I did not find a
rare apple on each trip.

One very memorable apple
visit was when Albert Handy took me to see Morgan Handy who was 100 years and
two months old. Mr. Handy had an incredible memory, describing to me in great
detail eight apples: ‘Cathead,’ ‘White Sweetning,’ ‘Queen,’ ‘Golden Harvest,’
‘Clarke’s Pearmain,’ ‘White Harvest,’ ‘Streaked Sweetning,’ and ‘Candy
Sweetning,’ the big tree in the bottom-land at Stone Mountain State Park. I
eventually found all of Mr. Handy’sapples.

Memories such as those of Mr.
Handyare very important because I
record them and then when I find an apple that is a good fit, I show them to
the people for identification. As an example, Press Wyatt told me about a
‘Hayes Green’ apple that had been in the Vannoy area; it was very large,
pointed, always green, having course texture, sour, and ripened very late.
Later, I was in a Robbinsville cove (212 miles away) looking at a ‘Howard’
apple tree as I started to depart; I came to a home with six apple trees. The
owners knew the identity of five of them, but as soon as I saw the sixth I said
to myself, “This could be the Hayes Green”. 
Press Wyatt confirmed that it was the Hayes Green apple.  Half the apples I have found were unknown
apples that I had to identify myself.

Amazing Apple Diversity

There is something very
different about Wilkes
County as compared to
other counties –the great diversity of its apples. Usually every apple tree at
each house is different and they are all different at the next house. Several
people have told me that their parents and grandparents took pride in having
apples different from their neighbors; apparently this was a county-wide

As an example on Traphill
Road, in about 1.6 miles at eight sites, I found the following apples: ‘Father
Abraham,’ ‘Old Fashion Winesap,’ ‘Quince’ (apple), ‘June Harvest,’ ‘Wolf
River,’ ‘Sweet,’ ‘Stump,’ ‘Rusty Pippin,’ ‘Horse,’ ‘Sheepnose,’ ‘Houch,’ ‘Dula
Beauty,’ ‘Mountain Limbertwig,’ ‘Stripes,’ ‘Darnell,’ ‘Scott’ and ‘Red
Harvest.’  Years ago there were many more
varieties at these same locations, plus a very large orchard with reportedly
dozens of apple varieties. Sustaining these old varieties was made easier by
the large number of apple grafters. In talking to the older community members,
I had the impression that 70 years ago every other home had a member who could
graft apple trees. In Wilkes County
it is unusual to see a graft line on a tree, because they practiced “root
grafting”, where the scion wood was grafted onto a piece of root they had
dug-up, then when it was planted, the graft union was below ground level.

The ‘Horse’ apples that I
mentioned on Traphill Road
were always a faulty-looking dirty yellow/red. I observed these very
unimpressive-looking apples for seven years. On the eighth year, I was
astounded — the apples were larger and they were a clear bright yellow that
changed to a brilliant red blush; the most beautiful apples you would see in a
lifetime. Then the next and succeeding years the apples were back to their
yucky appearance. This does illustrate one thing: the potential great
appearance of any of the heritage apples if properly grown.

The ‘Black Beauty’ Apple

Over twenty people had
mentioned the ‘Black Beauty’ apple. It was in western North
Carolina plus Virginia and Kentucky. In 2001,I had collected apples from four
different trees that somewhat fit the ‘Black Beauty’ description. My plan was
to go to Wilkes County and take the apples to four homes
where the ‘Black Beauty’ apples had been mentioned.

My first stop was at the home
of Weaver Gray, who lived just across the Wilkes/Yadkin County line. It turned
out that he had heard of the Black Beauty but not seen one. Weaver told me that
someone had brought him some apples from the nearby farm of Junior Johnson (the
legendary NASCAR driver). “The apples are on my washing machine, why don’t you
take some and see if you can identify them,” he said and they also fit the
‘Black Beauty’ description.

My next stop was in the
Purlear section of western Wilkes at the home of Bud Reid, who had a dead
‘Black Beauty’ tree just across the road. I presented my five bags of apples;
both Bud and his wife, Patsy, excitedly pointed to the ‘Junior Johnson’ apples
and said, “This is the’ Black Beauty.'” Junior had built his home and Black
Angus farm complex at an old farm site with twenty apple trees:  ‘Blacktwig,’ ‘Winter Fleming,’ ‘Long Stem,’
and seventeen ‘Black Beauty’ trees. He allowed me to get cuttings from the

One year Junior said, “How
about grafting my apple trees since they might not always be here?” I did graft
him a tree of each type and when I took them back in the fall, I was shocked —
the cows and the trees had happily co-existed for many years, but three days
before I arrived the cows had stripped the bark from the trees (from about 1
foot high to 6 feet). The trees all eventually died.

A person might look at my
long list of Wilkes apples below and say, “They are probably just Seedlings”.  I would strongly disagree with that
thought.  These apples are of good
quality and had valuable uses in the community. 
It is my opinion, that years ago, these apples were actually dispersed
over a wide geographic area.  For
instance the Strawberry Rome apple was mentioned in a very small Wilkes County
area; but at a festival where I had one of the apples on display; a lady came
by and said that they previously had the Strawberry Rome apples in Pennsylvania.

Wilkes County Apples Found

Adam and Eve, American
Beauty, Aspirin, Aunt Sally, Arkansas Black, Baldwin, Balsam, Baltimore Pound,
Baltimore Red, Banana (3 types), Banana Sweet, Bank, Barker’s Liner, Barrel,
Bausel, Bellflower, Ben Davis, Benson, Bevan’s Favorite, Big Limb,
Billy Sparks Sweetning, Bingham, Bitter Queen, Black Beauty, Black Ben Davis,
Blacktwig (Mammoth Blacktwig), Blood Red Crab, Blue Skin, Bob, Branch, Brandy,
Brushy Mountain Limbertwig, Buchanan, Buckeye Beauty, Buckingham, Bumblebee
Sweetning, Buncombe, Burnskin, Butter, Candy Sweet, Canning, Cannon Pearmain,
Carolina Keeper, Cat, Catawba, Cathead Queen, Cheese (3 types), Church,
Clarke’s Pearmain, Clem Byrd, Clominger, Coffee Seedling, Cothren, Cotton, Cotton Sweet, Crack, Crack Open (Winter Green),
Crouch, Curtis Cheese, Daddy (2 types), Daisy Sweet, Darnell, Davis, Doch,
Donce, Doss Blushing June, Dula Beauty, Durham, Early Colton (Colton), Early
Harvest, Early June (2 types), Early Pickens, Early Sweet June, Early
Sweetning, Early Transparent, English Russet, Everhart, Fall, Fall Rose, Fall
Sweet, Fall Sweetning, Fallawater, Father Abraham, Fernina Pippin, Flanagan,
Flat, Flat Top, Forward (sweet), Forward Streak, Frog, Garden, Gibson, Golden
Harvest, Golden Sweet, Golden Twig, Goose Pasture, Gragg, Granny, Granny Blair,
Grave, Greasy, Greasy Skin, Green Pearmain, Green Pippin, Green Skin, Green
Skin Sweet, Green Sweet, Grickson, Grimes Golden, Grindstone, Gruff, Half Acre,
Hall, Harper’s Seedling, Hawkeye, Hayes Green, High Top, Hillside, Hincher
Queen, Hog, Hog Pen, Hollow Log, Horse (3 types), Horseshoe, Houch, House,
Huckleberry, Ice, Improved Early Harvest, Improved Queen, Jack, Jenny Beauty,
Jewel Smoker, John Conner, Johnalee, Johnny, Johnny No Core, Johnson Fine
Winter, Johnson Keeper, Jonah, Jonathan, July Stripe, June Harvest, June Pink,
June Stripie, June Sweet, Kane, King David, Kitchen, Knob, Ladonium, Ladyfinger
(pointed), Larry, Late Queen, Leathercoat, Liddy, Lieby, Link, Little
Limbertwig, Liveland Raspberry, Long
Stem, Maiden Blush, Mammy, Mausby’s Fine Winter, May, McCuller’s Winter, Milam,
Mongolean, Morgan’s Christmas, Mountain Limbertwig, New York World, Night
Dropper, Nim, No Bloom, Notley P, Nursery, O. F. Yellow Delicious, Oat, Ode,
Old Fashion Limbertwig, Old Fashion Stayman, Old Fashion Winesap, Old Field,
Ozark Pippin, Paragon, Patrick Red, Payne (2 types), Pear (apple, lg. pointed),
Pear Sweetning, Pike, Pinkerton, Plum, Plymouth, Polk Berry, Polk Seedling,
Polkberry Red, Pound (3 types), Pound Russet, Puff, Pumpkin, Pumpkin Sweet,
Queen (2 types), Queen Beauty, Quince (apple), Quincy, Red Astor, Red
Astrachan, Red Bird (late), Red Buckingham, Red Delicious, Red Harvest, Red
Horse, Red June (pointed), Red June (round), Red Kane, Red Limbertwig, Red
Pearmain, Red Potts, Red Queen, Red Streak, Red Sweet, Red Sweet June, Red
Winesap, Red Winter Sweet, Reed, Roberts, Robinson, Roman Beauty, Royal
Limbertwig, Rubin Queen, Rustic, Rusty Coat, Rusty Coat Sour, Rusty Coat Sweet,
Rusty Delicious, Rusty Pippin, Rusty Sweet, Rusty Sweetning, Sal, Sally, Scarlet
Stayman, Scott, Seedling Limbertwig, Senator, Sheep, Sheepnose, Slope, Soda,
Sour June, Sour Sweetning, Speckled Red, Spice (2 types), Springdale, Stable,
Strawberry, Strawberry Rome, Streaked Sweetning, Stripe, Striped Ben Davis,
Striped Delicious, Striped Early Harvest, Striped Horse, Striped June, Striped
Queen, Striped Sweet, Striped Virginia Beauty, Stripes, Stuart’s Golden, Stump,
Sugar, Sugar Ball, Summer Champion, Summer Cheese, Summer Pink, Summer Queen,
Summer Rambo, Sunday Sweet, Sweeny, Sweet (4 types), Sweet Abram, Sweet Bough,
Sweet Horse, Sweet Limbertwig, Sweet Potato, Sweet Pound, Sweet Queen,
Tenderskin, Tennessee Beauty, Tough Hide, Transcendent Crab, Twenty Ounce,
Two-Tone, Vandever June, Vanhoy, Virginia Beauty, Water Core (2 types), Water
Core Sweet, Water Spout, Watermelon, Waterous, Watts Limbertwig, Wealthy,
White, White Buckingham, White Fall Pippin, White Harvest, White Horse, White
Limbertwig, White Pipka, White Sweet, White Top, Will, Wilson’s Red June,
Winter Fleming, Winter Green, Winter Neverfail, Winter Spice, Winter Sweet,
Wolf River, Woody, Yellow Bank, Yellow Beauty, Yellow Hard, Yellow Hardin,
Yellow June, Yellow Meat, Yellow Potts, Yellow Queen , Yellow Sweet, Yellow
Sweet June, York Pippin, and Yorkshire.

Wilkes County Apples Awaiting
Discovery (not yet found)

Ann Seedling, Ashmead’s
Kernel, Barnyard, Bee Gum, Ben’s Favorite, Bergy, Black Mammoth, Brock,
Chocolate, Corn Meal, Dad, George Little Sweet, Delawine, Fall Cheese,
Granddaddy,Grandma, Kinnaird’s
Choice, Lady Washington (red & yellow), Ladyfinger (round), Logheap, Mealy
Core, Mule’s Head, Neverbloom (No Bloom?), Neverfail, New York Pippin, Nickel
Apple, Old Fashion Slit, Paint, Pate, Pear (apple, small), Petty Special, Pink,
Queen of Haywood, Randall, Roxbury Russet, Sclonce Core, Seven
Prong, Shockley, Sidewinder (York?), Snowball, Sow, Spring, Summer Pearmain,
Sun, Sweet Pippin, Swing Apple, Tommy Richard, Well House, Willow, Winter
Bowman, & Winter Pearmain.

Heart-felt appreciation is extended to all those who
assisted my Wilkes
County apple search.

Photos by Tom Brown