The Best Tomatoes to Grow Where You Live

Enjoy bumper tomato harvests. Organic gardeners with broad experience of multiple varieties recommend the best tomatoes to grow in your region.

| February/March 2010

  • Regional Gardening Map
    In some regions, tomatoes must cope with high heat and humidity. In other areas, short growing seasons and cold temperatures are the biggest challenges.
  • best tomatoes - multiple varieties
    Last fall, we conducted an online survey asking readers about the best tomatoes that grow where they live. More than 2,000 people responded, telling us their favorite varieties and offering helpful tomato-growing tips.
  • Tomato 3
    ‘Brandywine’ tomatoes. This variety was No. 1 in the “Slicer” category — the main-crop tomatoes used for making sauce and also eaten fresh.
  • Tomato 14
    The entire category of “cherry tomatoes” was very popular. These small tomatoes come in a rainbow of colors, and, because they mature quickly, they are especially valued in regions with short growing seasons.
  • Tomato 2
    ‘White Beefsteak’ tomatoes. Beefsteak varieties came in No. 1 in our category of “Really Big” tomatoes — those that often produce fruits weighing a pound or more.
  • Tomato 4
    ‘Stupice’ tomatoes. This variety ranked high in the “Saladette/Pear” category.
  • Tomato 5
    ‘Green Zebra’ tomatoes. This variety was a favorite “non-red.”

  • Regional Gardening Map
  • best tomatoes - multiple varieties
  • Tomato 3
  • Tomato 14
  • Tomato 2
  • Tomato 4
  • Tomato 5

The surest way to have a successful tomato crop is to grow varieties with a proven track record in organic gardens in your area. Last fall, we conducted an online survey asking readers about the best tomato varieties for their regions, and we got even more great information than we expected!

In addition to naming names, our 2,000 respondents offered up a treasure-trove of useful tips. Some of the best of these appear in the regional lists of top tomato varieties below. Additional regional tomato-growing tips appear on our regional gardening pages.

Tomato Lover’s Profile

Our survey was open to anyone. Many members of the MOTHER EARTH NEWS Gardening Advisory Board weighed in on what they view as the best tomatoes, as did folks from Seed Savers Exchange and various online gardening forums. Many gardeners with only a few years of experience didn’t suggest varieties, but instead begged for help! Gardeners with more experience shared many variety recommendations.

Many gardeners had common purposes, with more than 44 percent of respondents saying they hoped to grow enough tomatoes “to eat fresh, preserve and share.” More than 66 percent use only organic methods, with compost and aged manure the top choices for fertilizers. About half of the survey-takers reported that tomatoes are easy or moderately easy for them to grow, with more difficulty noted in extreme climates.

Tomato Varieties and Types

It was easy to tally up scores for well-known varieties such as ‘Amish Paste’ or ‘Early Girl,’ but several variety groups presented identification problems. As I combed through the lists, “beefsteak” and “roma” formed large generic categories, so they are treated that way for ranking purposes. ‘Brandywine’ should be considered a generic category as well, because it was impossible to identify strains that vary in color from pink to yellow to black.

For organizational purposes, the survey sorted tomatoes into the following types:

4/4/2018 9:17:23 AM

Last year I planted seeds from Campart tomatoes bought at the store. I had three plants come up and each plant had at least fifty golf ball size tomatoes or more. They grew amazing well and were delicious. Have you hears of where they sell the seeds and what are the name of the seeds? I am going to plant some more this year from the seeds(from the store). I live in central Fl. Planting now,

Southren Livin
3/1/2013 6:29:48 PM

amazing you left off the tastiest: marglobes and rutgers........



Learn at Home!

Register now to get access to ALL current video workshops and prerecorded webinars plus anything new that we add through the end of 2020.


Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 64% Off the Cover Price

50 Years of Money-Saving Tips!

Mother Earth NewsAt MOTHER EARTH NEWS for 50 years and counting, we are dedicated to conserving our planet's natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. You'll find tips for slashing heating bills, growing fresh, natural produce at home, and more. That's why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.95 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.95 for 6 issues.

Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
International Subscribers - Click Here
Canadian subscriptions: 1 year (includes postage & GST).

Facebook Pinterest Instagram YouTube Twitter flipboard

Free Product Information Classifieds Newsletters