How to Make Your Own Mayo

| 4/14/2015 9:36:00 AM

Tags: mayonnaise, Maryland, Ilene White Freedman,

Time to make your own mayonnaise! Making homemade mayo is bigger than saving a couple bucks. It takes minutes to whip up a batch and then you feel like you have bested the commercial industry as a whole. It proves that we can do for ourselves. Mayonnaise may be the simplest empowerment tool for the do-it-yourself Viking.


Making mayonnaise takes two minutes, one egg, and a cup of light oil. There is also a teaspoon of mustard, the juice of a lemon and a dash a salt. That’s it--for pure, light, creamy real mayonnaise. These ingredients cost $1.50, according to Make the Bread, Buy the Butter by Jennifer Reese.

So why don’t we make our own mayonnaise? Hellmann’s came onto the market in 1912. Miracle Whip followed in 1933, replacing real mayo with a cheaper mayonnaise product in a base of water and soybean oil. They offered the shortcut. It whisked away our knowledge of how to make a simple spread and now we spend $2 a jar, more for the good stuff, with no idea how easy it is to make fresh.  

Even Hellmann’s “real mayonnaise” has calcium disodium EDTA in it, a controversial preservative. Homemade mayo costs less, uses better ingredients and skips the preservatives, all in a few minutes.

Mayo Making Tips

It can be whisked and drizzled by hand, but that is a little like torture. My friend, Sarah, and I tortured ourselves, laughing, one holding up an arm to drizzle the olive oil slowly while the other was constantly whisking.  A test of endurance. Cuisinart to the rescue! Did you know there is a little hole in the bottom of the push top, special for this reason? Pour olive oil in the push top and it drizzles out the little hole into the mixing bowl.

4/27/2015 7:56:19 PM

It's true that homemade mayonaise doesn't keep as long, since the eggs are raw and nothing is heat-treated or pasteurized, so it generally only lasts a week or so. (And yes, sometimes necessity dictates certain compromises.) But in general, if it doesn't last forever, so what? Therein lies the appeal, I say, as the ingredients are fresh and haven't been de-natured by further processing and compromised by artificial preservatives. After all, something that never goes bad (think Big Macs, Cool Whip) isn't really worth eating.

4/27/2015 10:29:06 AM

I would suggest using a stick blender with a wide mouth pint mason jar for mixing this, the amounts make making this in a standard blender very hard. I altered this recipe a bit, using 1 whole egg, one egg yolk, and no it doesn't have to be room temp, 1/2 cup canola oil, 1/2 cup vegetable, 1 teaspoon spicy brown mustard, 1 tablespoon rice vinegar (unseasoned) and some freshly ground Himalayan pink sea salt to taste. Took only less than 2 minutes to blend with the stick blender.

4/27/2015 7:29:58 AM

I'm a French chef so it's not that I don't know how to make mayonnaise, it's that home-made mayo doesn't keep. I live alone and only consume about 2 TB a week, so I'm pretty well stuck with buying a jar. I would advise newcomers to the real thing to start with a mild oil with maybe a small proportion of virgin olive oil.

mother earth news fair 2018 schedule


Next: August 4-5, 2018
Albany, OR

Whether you want to learn how to grow and raise your own food, build your own root cellar, or create a green dream home, come out and learn everything you need to know — and then some!