Gardening Methods: Double-Dug, Rototilled, Rows or Deep Mulch Beds

Discussion of which gardening methods are best, including Biodynamic French Intensive double-dug versus rototilled beds, conventional straight rows or deep mulch, yields, space, fertilization, and long-term effects.


| July/August 1986


Reprinted from MOTHER EARTH NEWS NO. 92. 

Double-dug or rototilled bed? Straight rows or deep mulch? Which of these gardening methods is best?

An Experiment With Gardening Methods

Two summers ago, in 1984, our Eco-Village gardeners conducted an intriguing experiment: They grew the same vegetables (and identical numbers of each) using four different methods. The techniques they used in four minigardens were these: 

BFI: the hand-worked, biodynamic/French intensive technique, in which the soil is first loosened to a depth of two feet with a spade and fork and then shaped into a four-foot-wide raised bed.  

RB: the rototilled, raised-bed method, in which the entire area is rototilled and the loosened pathway soil spaded and raked up onto a four-foot-wide raised bed (then treated like the standard hand-dug biodynamic/French intensive garden).  

CR: a conventional row design, in which the entire plot is rototilled, then planted in single rows with pathways in between.  





mother earth news fair 2018 schedule

MOTHER EARTH NEWS FAIR

Next: April 28-29, 2018
Asheville, NC

Whether you want to learn how to grow and raise your own food, build your own root cellar, or create a green dream home, come out and learn everything you need to know — and then some!

LEARN MORE