Economics and Population

| 1/3/2012 4:04:57 PM

Until now most economic study has been preoccupied with the reasons one country’s economy is healthier than another’s. The comparisons help us discover the best practices. Over the years, we’ve improved economies by learning from each other and adopting the models that are most successful. On the whole, the evidence has demonstrated that nations with market-directed economies are more successful than those with centrally planned economies. The big centrally planned economies of China and the former Soviet Republics have, over the last few decades, converted to more market-driven systems. And they have found new prosperity.

Photo of Chinese factory by Bryan WelchEconomists have paid a lot more attention to the relative success or failure of national economies than to the larger dynamics of the world’s economy. Students of economics understand the reasons why one nation outperforms another better than they understand the fundamental forces that direct the human economy as a single entity or the symbiotic relationships that support groups of national economies. Likewise we find it hard to track economics across long periods of time. What events occurred in the 19th century that made some nations prosperous in the 20th century? Are events occurring today that might undermine our economic health 30 years from now? We’re pretty comfortable looking at one national economy and its condition today. When we aggregate more than one national economy and then try to track economic trends over time, the equation’s complexity increases by orders of magnitude. It’s difficult for the economist to get his or her arms around the global economy as it evolves across the decades.

Economists are aware of this gap in understanding. They recognize the complexity of their subject matter. They make allowances for what they call “externality.” In economics, “externality” refers to the effects of an economic event on parties not directly involved – people in faraway places, in the past or in the future. The most vivid illustrations of externality, these days, come from the environmental realm. The carbon we’ve added to the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels has had relatively little effect on the people who pumped the oil, sold the oil or burned the oil. Most economic studies quantify our reliance on fossil fuels as a logical reliance on a relatively abundant natural resource. Viewed in this way, fossil fuels have been a precious resource fueling prosperity and innovation for more than 100 years with almost no bad effects. If negative environmental consequences are not felt within the economy where the petroleum is produced or where it is burned, then those consequences are “externalities.” It is increasingly evident, however, that burning fossil fuels has a generalized effect on the health of the planet overall and that it will have an effect on the health and welfare of future generations.

Those effects are external to most economic models, and it’s hard to quantify them.

Economists are attempting to measure the effects of externalities like long-term environmental consequences. Economies that accurately evaluate the costs of their products are more efficient. If oil were taxed to pay reparations for the long-term environmental consequences of its extraction and consumption, then governments could use the additional revenues to mitigate the damage. Consumers might use less oil because it would be more expensive. Either way, the “externality” of environmental damage would be a measured factor in the economic equation. We would at least be aware of the true economic effects of our behavior.

Nigeria’s birthrate would be external to most equations measuring economic growth in the United States even though Nigerian labor provides a lot of affordable oil to Western industrialized nations, and lots of Nigerians emigrate to wealthy countries where they provide high-quality, low-cost labor. Africa’s population increase is not routinely measured as a factor in the economics of England, France or the United States. But effects are felt nonetheless in both negative and positive ways.

1/4/2012 12:30:55 PM

Good article. Nobody seems to be talking about the population problem & its role in the present economic situation troubling us. As a population grows along the path of the sigmoid, logistic curve, it reaches a maximum value at the carrying capacity. At that point, the birth rate equals the death rate and the population remains stable-- but that's also the point at which competiton for the resources that limit further grow becomes maximized......Humans are unique among the species in that we take care of our sick & less fortunate members, helping them to survive. But when competition for resources is maximized, there aren't any left-overs for our charitable contributions.....BTW- please stop demonizing oil: without oil we'd all be burning trees and dung to cook our tortillas & kassava, using up all our forests & fertilzer like they do in the Third World. Which is harder on the environment?....In order to maintain a stable GNP per capita (ie- individual wealth), then GNP must grow if population (capita) grows. A stable population does not require a growing economy (only the stock holders do).

Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 64% Off the Cover Price

Money-Saving Tips in Every Issue!

Mother Earth NewsAt MOTHER EARTH NEWS, we are dedicated to conserving our planet's natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. You'll find tips for slashing heating bills, growing fresh, natural produce at home, and more. That's why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.95 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.95 for 6 issues.

Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
International Subscribers - Click Here
Canadian subscriptions: 1 year (includes postage & GST).

Facebook Pinterest Instagram YouTube Twitter flipboard

Free Product Information Classifieds Newsletters

click me