How Did We Get Here? Tribal Identity and Accepting President Barack Obama

| 8/21/2009 3:21:50 PM

FlowersUntil fairly recently, the people we depended on lived nearby. Most human beings never traveled more than a few miles from their home. We lived and died in the same small group of people, typically, with one set of traditions and one language.

Among aboriginal societies it’s very common for the name of a tribe to be the equivalent of “the human beings” or “the people” in that tribe’s language. Out of almost 100 tribes listed on the website,[1] more than 30 define the name of their tribe in more or less that way — “the people,” “the original people,” “the best people,” (the “best people,” the Illiniwek from which the state of Illinois takes its name, now call themselves the Peoria, which means “backpack people”), or “the true people.”

Until recently we could afford the luxury of seeing our personal tribes as God’s chosen people. The Judeo-Christian Bible is, of course, full of these declarations. We consistently and systematically considered our local, tribal interests superior to the needs and interests of other people who spoke a different language and wore a different style of footwear.

To a surprising degree, our modern wars have been tribal wars. The Nazi movement, which catalyzed World War II, was explicitly a tribal movement designed to distinguish the Aryan race from other Europeans. Predictably, the people trying to distinguish themselves defined the “Aryans” as the original speakers of Indo-European languages and therefore, in their opinion, the “original people” of Europe.[2] The First World War’s proximate cause was the assassination of the Archduke Ferdinand, monarch of the Austro-Hungarian Empire, by Gavrilo Princip, a Serbian student inspired by the annexation of Bosnia by the Austro-Hungarians. A lot of Serbs lived in Bosnia-Herzegovina at the time. Princip evidently believed he was defending his ethnic heritage. The ethnic divisions of the Balkan States, including Bosnia Herzegovina, are cultural fault lines along which violence has often erupted. Like World War II, the First World War germinated in a tribal mindset.

A strong tribal identity must have been important to our survival. Durable ethnic divisions characterize human history in every part of the world. As our territories filled up and our communities grew closer together, though, we found ourselves trading with the strangers over the hill. Then our children began marrying within other communities. The next thing you know, it was hard to tell which tribe our grandchildren belonged to. Those grandchildren constituted the common interest between neighboring peoples.

As I write this my father and I are trying to heal a cultural rift in our own relationship. Day before yesterday he included me in a group e-mail to his siblings and several of my cousins. The email was a reprint of an open letter to President Obama written by a retired Proctor & Gamble sales executive named Lou Pritchett. In it, Pritchett repeatedly says to the president, “You scare me,” for a variety of reason, almost none of them directly related to actual public policy. The reasons Barack Obama scares Lou Pritchett — like my dad, a white guy in his 70s — range from the allegation that the administration wants to turn the United States into a “European-style country,” to the assertion that the president is, “culturally, not an American,” because he lived in his stepfather’s home country of Indonesia from age 6 to age 10. For better or for worse, I responded to all the recipients and suggested that my upbringing on the Mexican border and my subsequent Ivy-league education gave me a powerful sense of connection with the President, and that I resented the implication that either of us is “not an American,” culturally, ethnically, psychologically or otherwise.

Elton Lyon
12/10/2009 5:43:48 PM

I don't dislike Obama just because he is 1/2 black. I don't like the 1/2 white part either.

12/10/2009 4:05:29 PM

"To my eyes, Barack Obama personifies the greatest virtues of our diverse, progressive country." -I just swallowed the puke in my mouth. The greatest virtues? What great virtues? How about appointing communists to his administration. That's a great virtue. Communism steals freedom from the people. Nice. And what does "progressive" country mean? If that includes trashing our constitution, then that's not our country. The reason he got elected was because of populism. He said "change" and people cried. I hope you like your change now. Health care is a right given by government? Are you kidding me? I enjoy Mother Earth's articles about self sufficiency, but I am increasingly annoyed by it's ideological spewing bullcrap. Therefore I tend to read Country Side Living instead and will never buy the magazine.

11/9/2009 7:45:16 AM

I've been reading these comments. What exactly is HATE speech? Can someone honestly answer this? I hear alot about it being tossed around, but nobody wants to define it. Also, I am a native American. Not American indian. I was born and raised in America.My Grandmother, and her Mother were born and raised in America..... so, I'm American. I'm really tied of hearing.... well, if your great, great, great, great grandpappy was born in england, then you're not 'native american' poppy-cock! I was born and raised here.... and I don't like what I see going on in my country. It's not up to the government to financially take care of anyone... it's only up to the government to keep the entire nation safe... that is their ONLY function... and they " congress" haven't done a very good job of that. Also, would some people stop saying this 'mess' was handed to obama by President Bush. You seem to forget, he was a senator... he helped to create the mess!

Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 64% Off the Cover Price

Money-Saving Tips in Every Issue!

Mother Earth NewsAt MOTHER EARTH NEWS, we are dedicated to conserving our planet's natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. You'll find tips for slashing heating bills, growing fresh, natural produce at home, and more. That's why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.95 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.95 for 6 issues.

Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
International Subscribers - Click Here
Canadian subscriptions: 1 year (includes postage & GST).

Facebook Pinterest Instagram YouTube Twitter flipboard

Free Product Information Classifieds Newsletters