The USDA Label Says Grass-fed, but is It?

What does the USDA grass-fed label really represent? Grass-fed beef expert Jo Robinson explains.


| April/May 2008



USDA grass fed label

The Process Verified Shield tells you that a grass-fed beef product meets the USDA’s standards, but does it meet yours?


Illustration courtesy USDA

Labels that identify a package of beef as “grass-fed” don’t always tell the whole story. To ensure that the product is what it claims to be, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) tells us to watch for their “process verified shield,” but what exactly does that guarantee? We asked grass-fed beef expert Jo Robinson to explain.

MOTHER: What’s the story behind the shield? 

Jo Robinson: The shield only verifies that the beef meets standards for a grass-fed label as set by the USDA in October 2007, which were meant to define the term “grass-fed.” A definition was needed because all cattle eat grass for the first 6 to 12 months, but then most are shipped to feedlots and fattened on grain for the rest of their lives. Some producers marketed this meat as grass-fed even though the animals were actually finished in a feedlot.

MOTHER: What standards must be met to qualify?

Robinson: To qualify for the USDA grass-fed label, cattle must be fed only mother’s milk and forage (grass and other greens) during their lifetime. The forage can be grazed or consumed as hay or other stored forage. Also, the cattle must have access to pasture “during the growing season.” 

MOTHER: Are there any objections to the standards?

roberta anderson
9/29/2010 4:59:37 PM

You can trust labels from independent, third-party certifiers with transparent, rigorous standards and verification methods! You can compare label "report cards" on the Consumer Reports site: www.greenerchoices.org/eco-labels. One good example? Food Alliance Certified - Grassfed. In order to sell Food Alliance Certified Grassfed products, animals must be raised on pasture or range, where they can browse on an exclusive diet of grass and forage plants. Animals may not be fed grain or grain by-products, or receive hormone or antibiotic treatments of any kind. All Food Alliance Certified livestock producers must meet standards for safe and fair working conditions, soil and water conservation, and protection of wildlife habitat under the Whole Farm/Ranch Criteria, as well as healthy and humane animal treatment in compliance with relevant Livestock Criteria. Learn more at www.foodalliance.org/grassfed


david andrews
7/21/2009 3:09:06 PM

Grass fed beef can have the same marbling and texture of "regular" beef. Range beef is tougher beef, and has a strong, almost gamy taste, so proper grass fed beef is grass fed and then grass finished. It is the finishing process that makes beef tender, not so much corn or soy or any other grain. Finishing is where the beef is put in holding pens and fed (usually grain). It was once thought that the grain made the beef tender, but now we know it was keeping them in pens so that they get no exercise that did that, much as a human "couch potato" gets fat (and tender) with no exercise. It is very difficult to see or taste any real difference between proper grass fed beef and grain fed beef. One test to make sure you have real grass fed beef is to check the fat left in the pan after cooking. True grass fed beef fat will still be liquid as it cools to room temperature; grain fed or finished beef will be white and almost solid (think lard).


david andrews
7/21/2009 2:51:58 PM

Grass fed beef can have the same marbling and texture of "regular" beef. Range beef is tougher beef, and may have a strong, almost gamy taste, so proper grass fed beef is grass fed and then grass finished. It is the finishing process that makes beef tender, not so much corn or soy or any other grain. Finishing is where the beef is put in holding pens and fed (usually grain). It was once thought that the grain made the beef tender, but now we know it was keeping them in pens so that they get no exercise that did that, much as a human "couch potato" gets fat (and tender) with no exercise. It is very difficult to see or taste any real difference between proper grass fed beef and grain fed beef. One test to make sure you have real grass fed beef is to check the fat left in the pan after cooking. True grass fed beef fat will still be liquid as it cools to room temperature; grain fed or finished beef will be white and almost solid (think lard).


olivia_1
9/4/2008 2:34:04 PM

Why is it so hard to buy good, healthy food? All these labels and shields are a good idea in theory, but if they don't go far enough and private entities start their own labels, who are we supposed to trust? I think in the end the labels, from "natural" and "organic, and now "grass-fed" end up being detrimental. You need to be very educated to understand the differences.






mother earth news fair

MOTHER EARTH NEWS FAIR

Oct. 21-22, 2017
Topeka, KS.

More than 150 workshops, great deals from more than 200 exhibitors, off-stage demos, inspirational keynotes, and great food!

LEARN MORE