Learn more about the super-insulated building technique that's popular in Saskatoon.
Super-insulated homes are able to withstand Saskatoon's harsh winters.
To get a closer look at the specialized building techniques involved in super-insulation construction, two of MOTHER EARTH NEWS' staffers visited Saskatoon (located in the Canadian province of Saskatchewan), where 14 such houses have been built as part of a regional Energy Showcase program.
Saskatoon typically experiences close to 11,000 heating degree-days annually (by comparison, New York, San Francisco, and Chicago have — respectively — 4,870, 3,000 and 6,175 degree-days each year), and is therefore an almost ideal spot to test the mettle of any purported energy-efficient housing concept. [EDITOR'S NOTE: Our traveling staffers were quick to report that Saskatoon's weather can be very severe. On one day during MOTHER EARTH NEWS' February trip, for example, the temperature stood at -25 degrees Fahrenheit, a figure that didn't take into account the wind whipping across the prairie. In the course of that day's shooting, our photographer temporarily set a plastic-coated cable release on the ground . . . only to have the wire snap in two when he tried to pick it up!]
Each of the builders then received a $6,000 compensation for the additional expenses that often go hand in hand with energy-efficient construction. (It's estimated that some $5,000 — or about 6 percent — of the cost of each project home resulted from the super-insulation features. However, builders are finding, now that they've constructed a number of these houses, that this expense can be reduced.) The residences ranged in price from $65,000 to $120,000 in Canadian dollars, with the average being around $85,000 ($1.00 Canadian equals roughly 80¢ U.S.). The approximate cost per square foot was between $40 and $45 ... again, in north-of-the-border currency. All of the homes were built on speculation and are now owned privately… and the buyers of the energy-efficient dwellings received a discount on their mortgage interest rates for taking part in the program.
• A continuous air/vapor barrier. The home's shell, basement, and ceiling are literally shrouded with sheets of 6-mil polyethylene, which are carefully overlapped and joined with acoustical sealant, a pliable butyl rubber compound.
• An air-to-air heat exchanger. These uncomplicated blower-augmented machines continuously suck fresh air into the house while exhausting stale air — thereby removing odors and pollutants, reducing humidity and reclaiming heat at the same time.
• Careful attention to glazing. The Energy Showcase homes typically have a window area equaling 5 to 10 percent of the total heated floor surface, a proportion similar to that of other houses in Saskatoon. However, all the designers tried to locate the majority of the windows toward the south to take advantage of solar gain, and they employed triple and/or quadruple glazing.
Essentially, the technique involves building two stud-framed walls (the interior one is load-bearing), with the air/vapor barrier placed behind the inner wall. Insulation is sandwiched between the studs of both walls. (This kind of construction allows most of the electrical, plumbing, and ducting work to be located within the interior wall, thus maintaining the integrity of the vapor barrier.) The R-values of the double walls used in the Energy Showcase homes varied from R-30 to R-60.
As already noted, the ceiling of a super-insulated home receives its own wrap of polyethylene, above which R-60 insulation is installed. In order to keep the vapor barrier unbroken, builders like to rely on exterior hatches for attic access, and avoid installing recessed ceiling-mounted light fixtures. The basement, too, is insulated — to a minimum of R-20 — and also has its own vapor barrier.
Most builders chose to install gas furnaces (in Canada, natural gas costs about $2.30/1,000 cubic feet as compared to an average of $4.50/1,000 in the U.S.). They've since discovered, though, that even the smallest units (rated at around 50,000 BTU/hour) produce far too much heat for the airtight dwellings. One of the showcase homes actually uses its domestic water heater, equipped with a circulating coil and forced-air blower, to provide all of its warmth. The owners say their total gas bill — for hot water and home heating — averages $10 to $15 a month.
For the past 13 months, the Energy Research Group of the Department of Mechanical Engineering of the University of Saskatoon has extensively monitored the energy consumption of all the homes. Every 15 minutes a computer records information on electricity and gas consumption, the temperature inside each house, and external weather conditions. In addition, Canada's National Research Council has monitored one home that has been left vacant for a year, conducting tests with simple electric space heaters and infiltration studies using tracer gas.
When the monitoring is finished and the data are evaluated, researchers should be able to pinpoint the precise design features (and flaws) that have the greatest bearing on a low-energy structure's performance.
On the whole, though, all 14 houses have proved more than satisfactory. Their wintertime energy consumption is dramatically low, and there have been no serious overheating problems in the warmer months. (Although Saskatoon's winters are savage, the summer daytime temperatures average above 70 degrees Fahrenheit.) Builders believe the minor overheating problems that have cropped up can be corrected by adding more overhang or installing shutters to limit summertime solar gain.
In all likelihood, the Saskatoon program will point the way toward establishing new standards of energy-efficient housing for cold-weather areas. Indeed, the impact of the Energy Showcase project is already apparent: Several hundred super-insulated homes have been built in Saskatoon since 1981 — and the provincial government has made interest-free loans available to builders of low-energy houses.
Super-insulated construction offers several advantages in addition to its fuel efficiency. First, it's a flexible building method that can accommodate many different housing designs. If the basic principles behind the technique (additional insulation in all areas including the basement floor, an airtight air/vapor barrier, an air-to-air heat exchanger, and attention to glazing) are adhered to, almost any plan could be used to produce a respectable energy performer.
Second, a super-insulated home isn't as dependent upon optimum solar siting as are typical passive or active sun-heated houses, and thus the construction method may prove to be a boon for folks forced to cope with locations that have less-than-favorable exposures.
Third, as many of the 45,000 persons who toured the Energy Showcase homes during October 1980 discovered, super-insulation is an unobtrusive technique. The foot-wide windowsills in the houses — which resemble bay windows from the interior — are about the only visible indications of the dwellings' unique construction.
In conclusion, while it remains to be seen whether super-insulation will eventually edge out the more "glamorous" forms of low-energy housing, one fact shines clear: Contractors can build affordable, comfortable airtight homes at reasonable prices and there's a city block of proof in a suburb of Saskatoon.
More than 150 workshops, great deals from more than 200 exhibitors, off-stage demos, hands-on workshops, and great food!LEARN MORE