Choosing Wind as a Source of Renewable Energy

Michael Hackleman and Claire Anderson explain how choosing wind as a source for renewable energy makes us less dependent on utility giants and nonrenewable, polluting fossil fuels.
By Michael Hackleman and Claire Anderson
June/July 2002
Add to My MSN

Harvesting wind as renewable energy.
PHOTO: COURTESY BERGEY WINDPOWER
Slideshow


Content Tools

Related Content

MAX Update No. 88: The Minimum Windscreen

A video demonstration of MAX's windscreen, which deflects air around the driver's face with minimal ...

Wind Power Worldwide

Find out which parts of the world have the most wind-generated electricity and check out these links...

Does the New Windspire Perform Better Than Other Vertical Axis Wind Turbines?

Vertical axis wind turbines don't always produce as much power as expected. Here's what we were able...

Worldwide Alternative Energy Investments Outstrip Fossil Fuel Investments

For the first time, investors put more money into alternative energy sources such as wind, solar and...

Choosing wind as a source for renewable energy makes us less dependent on polluting fossil fuels.

The wind picks up as the storm front moves in. While people scurry for cover and the trees dance in the blustery wind, a small machine on a slender pipe stands above the roads, houses and tall trees. It is a wind plant, an electricity generating turbine. A fearless reaper, it pivots on its tower to face the wind, propeller-like rotor already scything around, faster and faster. The rotor turns an attached generator, creating electricity with a simple elegance, carving energy from the sky.

In many parts of the continent, you can tap the power of the wind to generate nonpolluting renewable electricity for your home. Wind plant designs have improved so much — and the costs of oil, natural gas and nuclear power are so high — that many power companies are building large-scale wind plants. Farmers are being paid as much as $2,000 a year to lease one-eighth-acre sites for 200-foot-tall commercial wind plants. Experts predict wind-electric generation will soon become a major energy source in the United States.

Why Wind Power?

The more we rely on wind as a source for renewable energy, the less dependent we are on utility giants and nonrenewable, polluting fossil fuels. With world oil and gas supplies dwindling, experts estimate electricity prices will increase significantly in the coming years. A wind plant, especially in concert with a solar-electric photovoltaic (PV) system, is becoming a cost-effective way to meet the energy needs of sustainable homesteads.

To encourage the shift to wind and solar power, various government programs offer personal tax credits, property tax exemptions, low-interest loans and rebate programs. Some states, like California and Illinois, will reimburse up to 60 percent of your wind system costs. (To learn more about what's available in your state, contact a renewable energy dealer or check out the Database of State Incentives for Renewable Energy.)

Know Your Site for Wind Power

The map in the image gallery shows areas of the country likely to have sufficient wind speeds to run a home wind plant. Even if you're not located within the breezeways of the plains or the windy valleys of California, you still may be able to produce a portion of your power from wind. Your land's unique topography and microclimate can be more important than overall climatic trends. In the article "Choose the Right Site" (page 76 of this issue), you'll find details on how to determine if a specific location has enough wind to be a good wind plant site.

The idea of relying on the wind as an energy source may strike you as risky, since wind seems to be so variable from day to day. But wind actually acts in fairly predictable ways. Analysis of more than a half-century's recorded data, from thousands of sites, shows distinct patterns in both wind direction and speed through the seasons. The windiest months occur in winter, while the calmest winds are during summer. In terms of renewable energy systems, this means a marriage of wind (peaks in winter) and solar power (peaks in summer) can often provide the best power partnership. (For the latest on solar power options, see "Go Solar and Be Secure.")

Two distinct kinds of wind can be found at most locations. Prevalent winds blow frequently and reliably. Energy winds are storm winds or gusts that piggyback the prevalent winds and vary in velocity and duration. On average, there are seven days of prevalent winds and three days of energy winds in any two-week period. Oddly enough, while energy winds blow only one-third of the time, they contain 70 percent of the potential energy that can be harvested by a wind plant. While your region of the country might not be ranked as ideally suited for wind power, your individual microclimate paired with energy winds might yield enough energy to justify a wind plant system. 

The Math of Wind Power

Several variables — including the wind plant's size and design, and the site's wind speeds and duration — determine how much energy you can harvest from the wind. Power from wind is calculated using the formula:

Power = Swept area of rotor x Wind velocity3 x 1/2 Air density

You can increase power either by using a wind plant with a larger rotor or by placing your plant where it will receive stronger winds — usually on a hill or taller tower. (The third variable in the power formula, air density, doesn't vary much and isn't something you can control.) Note the total power in the wind is a function of the cube of the wind's velocity; just a small increase in velocity results in a much larger increase in power. For example, a 2.6 mph (a 26 percent) increase in wind speed from 10 mph to 12.6 mph will give you a 100 percent increase in power. To achieve this same increase using a larger rotor is usually a more expensive choice than placing a smaller rotor on a higher tower where it will receive stronger winds.

Wind Tower Power

In general, wind plants should be installed on a tower at least 20 feet taller than the tallest object within 400 feet. A tall, lightweight, guyed tower topped with a small (1-kilowatt to 10-kw) wind plant usually yields more bang for your buck than a larger wind plant positioned on a shorter tower.

There are several reasons to mount a wind plant on a tall tower. One is to gain clearance above trees, houses and other obstacles that create turbulence and reduce the power of the wind reaching the wind plant. Wind acts like water in the way it flows across any topography. It is slowed by obstacles such as trees, ridges and rocks, and is channeled by the overall shape of the terrain.

Not only does the wind get smoother at higher distances above the ground, it also increases in velocity. Most windspeed measurements are taken at a height of 6 feet because that's where wind affects us. But the wind speed is always greater higher above the ground. For example, a wind of 8 mph measured at 6 feet indicates a speed of 11.4 mph on a 36-foot tower and 13.9 mph for a 96-foot tower. So what, you say, we've raised the tower 60 feet higher, only to increase the wind speed by a mere 2.5 mph?

Remember the wind power formula: The power of the wind increases with the cube of the wind's velocity. So although the wind speed on top of a 96-foot tower increases just 25 percent compared to the 36-foot tower, the power of the wind reaching the taller wind plant increases 100 percent. The cost of an additional 60 feet of tower and rigging is generally less than the larger wind plant needed to give the same power increase. (To calculate wind power at different heights, visit the Windpower website.)

Sizing Your Wind System

Once you've determined you have a site with average ground-level wind speeds of at least 8 mph (which roughly translate into a speed of 13.9 mph on a 100-foot tower), then you'll need to decide what size wind plant and tower to buy.

Wind plants have both power (or peak power) and wind-speed ratings (rated power). The peak-power rating is usually more prominent, but is the least effective way to evaluate and compare wind plants. Bergey Windpower Sales Manager Steve Wilke says, "Trying to estimate the energy production of a wind turbine based on its peak-power rating is equivalent to trying to estimate the fuel economy of a car based on its top speed." Currently there are no set guidelines for wind plant ratings: Manufacturers can specify any wind speed to set their rated and peak-power ratings. While the rating might be accurate for a particular wind speed, it will not give you a true picture of how the wind plant will perform at your site, particularly at low wind speeds.

Instead of looking at the prominent peak power rating, you need to study the power production curve for each wind plant model. The amount of power the wind plant can produce varies greatly depending on the wind speed. The steep slopes on the power curve reflect how small increases in wind speed produce large increases in available energy. They also help illustrate the importance of having good information about the average wind speeds at your site before predicting how much power your wind plant will be able to produce.

Components and Costs

A complete wind-electric system includes the wind plant and tower, plus a controller, inverter, wiring and battery bank. Wind power expert Paul Gipe recommends buying from a dealer who offers a complete-system package, rather than trying to match components from various manufacturers.

The wind plant captures and transforms wind energy into direct current (DC) electricity. The wind plant must do more than convert the wind's energy into a rotary motion to power the electric generator. It must also automatically and reliably prevent rotor over-speed in high winds or risk damage from centrifugal forces. Finally, it must withstand turbulence, rain, sleet, ice, hail, lightning, corrosion and cold.

Home wind plant costs range from around $1,500 for a 1,000-watt rated wind plant to more than $20,000 for a 10-kw rated turbine. The higher-wattage plants, with their large-diameter, low-rotation-per-minute rotors, are designed to capture energy from low wind speeds. The less expensive models are usually high-speed, small-diameter rotors on lightweight units. Unfortunately, these smaller wind plants, a growing trend in home wind plant design, are proving too noisy for some neighbors in urban and rural areas. Upset neighbors have stopped small-scale wind plant installations or forced their eventual removal.

Paul Gipe has compiled data on the noise effects of several small wind plants. His review is available at www.chelseagreen.com/Wind/articles/noiseswt.htm. Even if you have no close neighbors, don't forget the noise levels of a wind plant with a high-speed rotor may adversely affect your own serenity. (Resist the temptation to mount any wind plant to the rooftop of your home to avoid using a tower. With the roof acting as a resonant chamber, you will be reminded your wind plant is working, day and night, like it or not.)

Wind plant rotors have either two or three blades. Wind plant expert Mick Sagrillo recommends three-bladed rotors. Sagrillo explains in his wind power video (see "resources," page 78 in this issue) that although each blade spoils, or reduces, the wind for the blade behind it, a three-blade rotor is able to yaw — move — freely. A two-blade machine goes through cycles of yawing and stopping, resulting in vibration that fatigues the machine's fasteners and welds fairly quickly, Sagrillo says.

More Wind Tower Power

Three main types of towers are suited for residential wind plants: freestanding, guyed and tilt-up towers. Most of us have seen freestanding towers gracing old farm pastures. Because they have a small footprint, freestanding towers are ideal for homeowners who have limited space. However, freestanding towers are expensive due to the amount of metal used in their manufacture.

Guyed towers are the cheapest towers available. A guyed tower consists of a slender pole tied to the ground by at least three guy lines. Both guyed towers and freestanding towers can be installed piece by piece — a task that's time-consuming and requires a crew of people — or can be assembled on the ground and lifted into place by a crane. Once in place, maintenance must be performed on both guyed and freestanding towers by climbing up to the wind plant: a job not for the faint of heart.

Tilt-up towers are a variation of guyed towers, but are braced with at least four guy lines for safe and easy raising and lowering. Unlike freestanding and standard guyed towers, they appeal to many people for their ease of maintenance. With the use of a winch and a small farm tractor or other large vehicle, the tower can be safely lowered to the ground and wind plant checks can be performed on terra firma. The tower is then raised again.

Budget between $1,300 and $10,000 for a tower, based on the size of the wind plant.

Even if you are connected to the grid, you may still want to include a small battery bank in your system to provide backup power if the grid goes down. If you are off the grid, then you will need to decide how large you want your battery bank to be. (You'll probably want to evaluate the benefits of a part-wind, part solar power system.) The battery bank must be sized to absorb the influx of wind-generated electricity and bridge the gap of windless (and sunless) periods.

Battery banks for small systems are usually built around 6-volt, deep-cycle, lead acid batteries. Similar in size and weight to a car battery, they have a service life of four to five years. Larger systems use batteries with larger cases, or one large single case for the whole bank. These cost more but are higher quality and may last as long as 10 years or more. The trick to a longer service life is periodic maintenance and limiting the depth of the discharge to no more than 50 percent of the bank's capacity.

While lead-acid battery technology is less efficient than some newer types, it is nearly a 100-percent-recycled industry, and at this point it offers a better overall cost/benefit ratio than nickel-cadmium or nickel-metal-hydride (NiMH) batteries for the typical renewable energy system.

Even a large battery bank takes up surprisingly little room. It can be placed in a corner of the garage, under a workbench, on a porch or in its own little shed. It must be vented to the outside if it resides indoors, and should be accessible for regular periodic inspections, and for adding any water lost to evaporation over time or from heavy charge or discharge rates.

Battery banks sized to handle the loads and provide a day or more of autonomy cost about $5 per watt. Wiring, disconnects, fuses and breakers, and code-compliant hardware will add a few more dollars per watt to the total.

If your wind plant power is for household use, you'll probably need an inverter — an electronic device that transforms low-voltage DC (direct current) power produced by the wind plant into the 110-volt AC (alternating current) electricity we usually find at the wall socket and most appliances run on. Inverters come in a variety of power ratings and are built to suit various needs. Depending on features, they cost $1 to $2 per watt.

The controller regulates voltage and current, protects the battery bank from overcharging, and monitors and displays system parameters like voltage, current and battery state of charge (often referred to by the acronym "SOC"). The controller also houses controls that may be adjusted to ensure the efficiency, safety and optimum performance of the wind-electric system.

The Bottom Line for Wind Power Systems

A small, 1,000-watt wind plant system on a 100-foot tower without batteries will cost from $5,000 to $12,000. With 12-mph average winds, it will produce about 2,400 kilowatt-hours per year. A large 10-kw system will cost $28,000 to $35,000 installed, and will produce 10,000 to 18,000 kwh per year. At current electric rates, these systems would have a simple payback period of 10 to 20 years in most areas. Government incentives can cut those costs by 50 percent or more. And if you are selling power back to the utility and electric rates increase (no one thinks they won't), then the economics of wind power become even better.

A wind plant may not be able to meet 100 percent of your energy needs, but it can offset your energy bills. As coal, oil and natural gas become more expensive, it is only a matter of time before wind machines and related renewable energy technologies — solar-electric PV modules, solar-thermal systems and microhydroelectric — will gain the attention and respect of people of every lifestyle who wish to power their dreams in a sustainable way.

Michael Hackleman has been installing and teaching about renewable energy for more than 30 years. He is the author of seven books for the do-it-yourselfer on solar, wind and microhydroelectric systems, and electric vehicles. He teaches workshops at the Midwest Renewable Energy Fair and Solar Living Institute each year.


Is Wind for You?

A small wind-energy system can provide you with a practical and economic source of electricity if:

  • Your property has a good wind resource
  • Your home or business is located on at least one acre of land, or your property is in a remote location that does not have easy access to utility lines
  • Your local zoning codes or covenants allow wind turbines
  • Your average monthly electric bills are $150 or more
  • You are comfortable with long-term investments.

Conserve Wind Power First

In most areas of North America, wind power alone probably will not be able to supply all of a home's power needs year-round. The average American household consumes 866 kilowatt-hours (kwh) per month — about 28 kwh per day — according to the U.S. Department of Energy. By switching to more efficient appliances, such as front-loading washers and compact fluorescent light bulbs, many people cut their energy usage in half. Conservation is always the cheapest first step. In the renewable energy trade, the rule is every dollar spent on conservation or higher-efficiency saves $3 to $5 in wind- or solar-electric system costs. (For a detailed discussion of conservation options, see "Save Energy and Money Now.")


Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next






Post a comment below.

 

George_33
7/4/2007 4:18:54 PM
I was realey impressed with your information.Thank you.








Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 66% Off the Cover Price

First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Lighten the Strain on the Earth and Your Budget

MOTHER EARTH NEWS is the guide to living — as one reader stated — “with little money and abundant happiness.” Every issue is an invaluable guide to leading a more sustainable life, covering ideas from fighting rising energy costs and protecting the environment to avoiding unnecessary spending on processed food. You’ll find tips for slashing heating bills; growing fresh, natural produce at home; and more. MOTHER EARTH NEWS helps you cut costs without sacrificing modern luxuries.

At MOTHER EARTH NEWS, we are dedicated to conserving our planet’s natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. That’s why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.00 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.00 for 6 issues.