Ask Our Experts

Answers to your questions about gardening, energy, homesteading and other sustainable living topics.

Add to My MSN

Are Old Canning Recipes Safe to Use?

5/8/2012 3:22:01 PM

Tags: canning recipes, safe canning

Canning RecipesI found a treasure trove of my grandmother’s canning recipes and am eager to use them. They use some interesting techniques, such as canning in the oven and flipping the hot, filled jars instead of using a water bath canner. Are there reasons why I shouldn’t use these canning recipes? 

When it comes to safe methods for canning foods, this is one instance in which modern advice is better than old-time techniques. The best way to be sure your home-canned foods are safe is to use only recipes that you know have been tested and verified safe by food scientists, who have learned a lot about food preservation over the years.

Two top publications are the most recent U.S. Department of Agriculture publication, So Easy to Preserve (fifth edition), which includes 184 tested recipes along with complete details for safe home canning, and the Ball Complete Book of Home Preserving. Another excellent source is Fresh Preserving, a website hosted by the Ball Corp., which manufactures jars and lids for home canning. This website includes more than 200 tested canning recipes.

Safe home canning depends on applying the proper amount of heat to kill microbes, and the amount of heat required depends in part on how the food is prepared, including what sizes the vegetables or fruits are cut into. Tested recipes have been monitored to confirm how much time (and for non-acid foods, how much pressure) is required for the heat to fully penetrate the pieces of food in whatever size jar is being used. Older hand-me-down recipes may not have ever been tested — there’s just no way to know. Precise acidity and salt/sugar levels are also important factors, which is further reason to always use recipes that have been tested by food scientists.

Older canning recipes sometimes call for unorthodox practices, such as flipping filled hot jars upside down to allow them to seal, or canning by setting the jars in an oven or out in the sun. Those methods aren’t acceptable for several reasons, says food scientist Karen Blakeslee of Kansas State University. While alternative methods may cause the jar to seal, Blakeslee says, they do not guarantee that the food inside has reached the proper temperature for storage.

You can change some things in tested canning recipes, though. “You can typically change spicing, or change the variety of peppers in salsas as long as you use the same amount,” Blakeslee says.

When canning fruits, you can reduce or eliminate sugar and can the fruit in water or fruit juice. Artificial sweeteners are not appropriate, however, Blakeslee says — they’re not heat-stable and will sometimes make your food bitter. Although the risks are probably low if you were to use your grandmother’s recipes, chances are you can find similar tested recipes from the previously mentioned sources.

— Robin Mather, Senior Associate Editor 


Robin Mather is a senior associate editor at MOTHER EARTH NEWS and the author of The Feast Nearby, a collection of essays and recipes from her year of eating locally on $40 a week. In her spare time, she is a hand-spinner, knitter, weaver, homebrewer, cheese maker and avid cook who cures her own bacon. Find her on .

Photo by Tim Nauman Photography 

Content Tools

Post a comment below.


7/8/2013 6:15:04 PM

Would these be the same scientist telling us GMO foods are safe?  I think if you follow the directions in your Ball Complete Book of Home Preserving you'll be fine.  PS, My grandmother managed not to kill her family using the old jars and methods.


7/8/2013 3:53:09 PM

Most counties have a cooperative extension Master Preserver Program which for a nominal fee and some volunteer work will train you in the fine and scientific art of preserving food.  The Cooperative Extension/The University of Georgia puts out a book called, SO EASY TO PRESERVE.  It has become my preserving bible since 2006.  It was definitely worth the money.  I also found that book I used for the 30 yrs before the U of GA book, STOCKING UP from Rodale Press  followed the correct procedure for nearly everything I can, freeze pickle or dry.  I still refer to both as well as checking out the USDA guide.  Safe food handling is paramount to my family's health.  The love of food preservation keeps me looking for updated ways and new recipes to add to my library.  Thanks for this article as well as a big thanks to Dave and Drum Sgt. Beaker for their good advice.

Dave Madden
10/21/2012 7:38:52 PM
Another great resource from the USDA is the "USDA Complete Guide to Home Canning, 2009 revision" available for free at:

6/13/2012 1:44:40 AM
I used to work for one of Ball's companies. We would get all kinds of calls about canning methods that were no longer recommended, including wax sealing, using glass jars with clasp lids and o-ring seals, upside down jars, etc. Home canners were also used to boiling their lids, when the lids out there now do not require boiling, just heating. It is best to follow the most recently recommended practices in order to have safe food and more assurance of sealing.

Subscribe Today!

Pay Now & Save 67% Off the Cover Price

(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here