I’ve read your reports about the problem of grass clippings, compost, manure and hay being contaminated with herbicide residues that can harm garden plants. Is there a way to screen these materials before I bring them into my garden?
Asheville, North Carolina
You are right to be concerned about the risk of herbicides lurking in organic materials. The pesticides of concern are clopyralid and aminopyralid, both in the “pyralid” class. Here are some simple tests you can use to screen organic materials to be sure they don’t contain traces of these herbicides.
To test compost, set up at least six 4-inch seed pots, and fill half of them with potting soil. Fill the other half with a mixture of two parts of the compost you want to test and one part potting soil, and be sure to label the pots. Plant the containers with peas (in cool weather) or beans (in warmer conditions). If pyralid herbicide residues are present, germination will be poor, and seedlings that do grow will have curled leaf edges.
To test manure, plant at least six seedling pots with peas or beans, and let them grow for a couple of weeks. Mix a slurry of equal parts manure and water, and strain off 2 cups of liquid. Drench half of the seedling pots with the manure water; water the others as usual. If the manure is tainted, symptoms will appear within a few days.
To test mulch, use the same procedure as with manure, but soak the hay or other materials overnight before straining off the water.
To read more about this pesticide problem, search for “killer compost” at www.MotherEarthNews.com. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) says it is working on this problem, but it needs to hear from gardeners that it is simply unacceptable to allow such persistent and potent herbicides to be marketed. We suggest you send comments to Richard Keigwin, director of the EPA’s Special Review and Reregistration Division, at firstname.lastname@example.org.
— Cheryl Long, editor in chief,
and Barbara Pleasant, gardening editor
Above: Gardeners beware! Two persistent pesticides are turning up in compost piles. Photo by ISTOCKPHOTO/ James Pauls