Make Organic Compost for Your Garden

Making and using organic compost improves the overall health of your garden. Includes essential steps for composting, how to use compost, benefits of composting, and materials to use for composting.


The gardener delights in good harvests; the garden delights in good compost.


Content Tools

Making and using organic compost are the most important things you can do to improve your garden. 

Make Organic Compost for Your Garden

Rural author Wendell Berry once wrote of the farmer, "He has seen the light lie down in the dung heap and rise again in the corn." These words have sharply clarified for me the agricultural life cycle — or, even better, light cycle . Plants convert solar energy into food for animals (ourselves included). Then the wastes from those animals, along with dead plant and animal bodies, "lie down in the dung heap," are composted, and "rise again in the corn."

This cycle of light is the central reason that composting is such an important link in organic food production: It returns solar energy to the soil. In this context, such common compost ingredients as onion skins, hair trimmings, eggshells, vegetable parings, and even burnt toast are no longer seen as garbage, but rather as sunlight on the move from one form to another.

By making use of such substances, composting enables us to have large amounts of "dung" for our gardens without necessarily passing most of the ingredients through an animal first. It also greatly speeds up the earth's own soil-building processes so we can get the results in months instead of centuries.

The benefits of using organic compost are so legion that it's no exaggeration to say that it is the key to soil fertility. The end product of composting is humus , the broken-down organic matter that is the basis of soil life. And the billions of microorganisms that are in a single teaspoon of fertile soil perform numerous functions. They change nutrients into a form that your plants ran use . . . provide a sustained, ongoing flow of that food . . . and bind earthen particles into small aggregates, helping to build a friable soil.

There are other benefits of organic compost:

Control of pH. Acid or alkaline soil can lock up many nutrients so that they're unavailable to plants. The regular addition of compost rounds off such sharp edges, helping to bring soil to the crop-favoring pH range of between 6.5 and 7.5.

Heat absorption. Finished compost will help darken most soils, helping them to better absorb heat from sunlight. This can actually extend your spring and fall growing seasons.

Drainage, water retention, and aeration. Imagine the life of a root for a moment, ever tunneling in search of water and food. If the soil is clayey, the roots will have trouble making headway. They become shallow, never reaching the food and water reserves deeper down. And their oxygen supply is easily cut off in the tightly packed soil.

Sandy soil creates a different problem; it's like a long stretch of good road with nowhere to get food and water. Nutrients and moisture simply percolate down out of reach.

So we want it all — good drainage, good water retention (even though the two sound almost contradictory), and openness for the incorporation of air. Again, humus is the cure-all. It opens up packed soils and binds together loose ones. Acting somewhat like a sponge, humus helps hold moisture, food, and air so plants can have access to them at will.

Nutrient retention. Chemical fertilizers provide quick-fix doses of three major nutrients: nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P), and potassium (K). Since such garden additives are highly water-soluble, plants can take them up quickly, but they can also be easily washed away by rain or irrigation. In fact, it's estimated that from 25% to 85% of the chemical nitrogen applied to soil and 15% to 20% of the phosphorus and potassium are lost to leaching.

Humus holds those water-soluble nutrients inside itself, keeping them safe from runoff and releasing them slowly to plants. (Even better, the soil microorganisms in humus release nutrients more slowly during cool weather — when crops are growing more slowly — and most quickly during warm weather, when plants are growing most actively.)

Free choice feeding. The way in which roots and humus directly interact is probably the most fascinating argument that I know of for the use of compost. It's a miraculous process whereby plants choose their own diet.

You may have seen the words cations exchange on a soil test. Cations are positively charged molecules of different minerals like ammonium, iron, potassium, magnesium, and calcium. Since opposites attract, the negatively charged molecules of humus (and, to a lesser extent, clay as well) attract and hold the positive canons.

When a searching root comes along, surrounded by an aura of positive hydrogen ions, it strikes up a friendly exchange with the humus (or clay) molecules: The root trades its hydrogen ions for the nutrient ions of its choice. Thus humus allows plants to choose what nutrients they need.

And more. Compost also helps control nematodes and soil diseases . . . attracts soil-building earthworms . . . helps plants produce their own growth stimulators . . . helps fix heavy metals and other toxins in the soil (instead of letting them be absorbed by the crops) . . . adds trace minerals to the soil . . . and makes plants hardier and more resistant to insects and diseases. It can even be used as a healing poultice on tree wounds!

Last, compost can be made virtually free at home, by mimicking the earth's recycling system. Chemical fertilizers, on the other hand, cost money and use nonrenewable fossil fuels (both as ingredients and in their manufacture).

Composting requires nitrogen, carbon, air, water, mass, and microorganisms.  

Where to Compost

Well, are you convinced? I hope so. Composting really is the backbone of good horticulture.

If you are ready to start your own pile of black soil magic, the first concern is where you'll build it. When choosing a spot, take into account these suggestions:

1. Try to locate your pile near your garden — a wheelbarrow loaded with compost is heavy.

2. If you're going to be importing some compost-building ingredients by vehicle, try to build your pile in a spot you can drive to.

3. Wetting the pile will be a lot easier if you locate near a water source.

4. A good deciduous shade tree near the pile can provide some shelter from heavy thunderstorms and excessively hot summer sun, while it lets warmth-boosting fall and winter light through. It'll even provide leaf material! However, evergreens (which have acidic needles), walnuts (which exude a toxin through their roots), and eucalyptuses (which have resinous leaves) are not good choices.

Compost In What

Now we need something to put your ingredients in. Actually, a straight-sided pile can be constructed with no bin or supports. That's a perfectly acceptable way to compost.

But it takes time to shape a freestanding pile; being able to toss the makings into a container can really speed the process along. In addition, if your neighbors live nearby, they may voice aesthetic objections to a freestanding pile of decomposing materials. In that case, you can compost incognito by using an attractive homemade or commercial bin. Privacy fencing (plant or wire) might also help shut out the critical eyes.

The creative scrounger will find that numerous materials make good bin buildings. Boards, poles, screen, wire, old pallets, concrete blocks, snow fencing, and hay bales will all serve well. At the other end of the spectrum are the $70 to $200 commercial composters you can buy through garden supply catalogs.

In the middle, between total scrounging and total spending, are the two composters we recently designed at MOTHER EARTH NEWS. The "quickie" version is a mobile pen made out of hogwire panels. This low-cost model allows you to use it to make a pile and then easily move the pen when you want to start a new pile or turn the old one. The "uptown" model is meant to be more aesthetically acceptable, yet still entirely practical. Although you could build it with just one bin (the design is basically modular), you'll do better if you build more than one enclosure so you can turn compost from one bin to the other. Better still, build a three-bin version so you can turn two half-decomposed "side" piles into the middle bin to finish cooking!

Any pile, freestanding or contained, should be at least 3 feet by 3 feet by 3 feet to insure that there's sufficient mass for the composting process to take place. I find 4 feet-tall by 5 feet-wide ones even better. The bottom of the pile should be exposed to the earth, and the top should be covered with black plastic or a waterproof tarp to protect it from extreme rain or drying sun. Contained piles should also have enough open spaces in their sides to allow for good air circulation.

Kosher and Nonkosher Organic Compost Materials

So many types of organic matter can be composted that it's almost easier to list what shouldn't be put in a compost pile. Here's a partial list of what not to use:

Cat feces. While almost every other kind of animal manure makes an excellent compost ingredient, cat feces can contain a parasite ( Toxoplasma gondii ) or roundworm ( Toxocara catty ). Either of these organisms can spread serious disease to pregnant women, unborn babies, and children.

Grease and fat. OK in small amounts, but too much will clog up the composting process.

Coal, coal ashes, and barbecue briquettes. These have overly high amounts of iron and sulfur (and who knows what else in the briquettes).

Diseased plant matter. Actually, you can place diseased plants in the center of a compost pile that will be prepared in the hot method — where temperatures reach a pathogen-killing 140 degrees Fahrenheit. Otherwise, burn them before composting.

Polyester, plastics, and other synthetics. They just don't rot.

Urban floor sweepings. In high-traffic areas, these can contain as much as 500 parts per million of lead.

Food preserved with BHT. Recent research has shown that even very small amounts of this antioxidant can alter plant growth profoundly.

Overly bulky or hard material. Cornstalks, sunflower stalks, nutshells, sticks thicker than a pencil, large bones, and oyster and clam shells should be shredded or pulverized before composting. If you can't do that, put them in a long-range pile of their own or burn what you can and add the ashes.

Sludge. Commercially reprocessed sludge is an increasingly popular soil amendment and is almost certainly pathogen-free, but I'm concerned about the heavy metals and insecticides it may contain.

And what are good compost makings? Well, for starters, how about these:

Plant residues (preferably nonsprayed), such as kitchen and garden wastes, weeds, grass clippings, leaves (go light on those from eucalyptuses, walnuts, and evergreens), straw, hay, hedge clippings, seaweed, aquatic plants, and green manure crops.

Commercial wastes, such as buckwheat hulls, rice hulls, molasses-making residue, spent hops, fruit-processing wastes, commercial fishing scraps, lake dredgings, sawdust, feathers, wood ashes (in moderation), utility-company tree trimmings, and vegetable or dairy wastes from grocery stores.

Home wastes, like eggshells, hair, wool scraps, etc.

Manures from horses, fowl, cows, pigs, sheep, etc. These are even better if they're mixed with straw (i.e., used stall bedding).

The Six Essentials for Home Composting

Once you've assembled lots of appropriate organic matter from the "compost pile shopping list" above, you're just about ready to start cooking. The funny thing, though, is there is no one way to make compost — indeed, there are almost as many methods as there are experts to advocate them.

It's like baking bread: There are thousands of different recipes, but all of them have in common some basic practices and vital main ingredients. So before you build that long-awaited heap, let's quickly review the six essentials of successful composting:

Nitrogen. For a compost to cook properly and to have maximum value for plants, it needs nitrogen, the leaf-growth-promoting element. Good sources of N are pig, chicken, sheep, horse, and cow manure (ranked in descending amounts of nitrogen) . . . fresh green plant waste (especially legumes) . . . kitchen wastes . . . blood, bone, cottonseed, hoof, horn, and alfalfa meals (readily available from garden supply centers, but somewhat costly) . . . and urine. This last nitrogen source may be animal or — if you're not made squeamish by the thought — human. Indeed, "household liquid activator," as human urine has been dubbed, is practically sterile, available to everyone, and a perfect nitrogenous compost catalyst. (You can collect it in a lidded bucket — a chamber pot, our forebears called it — and dilute it with water, then add it once the pile is hot. A week's urine should provide plenty of N for a good-sized pile.)

Carbon. The vast bulk of any compost pile should be carbonaceous material: dried leaves, hay, straw, partially dried garden gleanings, shredded stalks — almost any dried organic matter. This is the key humus-building material and the substance that binds nitrogen (an otherwise ephemeral element) into the compost.

Air. Although organic matter can decay anaerobically (without oxygen), it will do so much quicker, retain more nutrient value, and — for that matter — cook with much less stink if it composts aerobically (with oxygen). To provide good airflow to a pile, you should, if possible, place thick, hollow material like cornstalks and sunflower stalks at the bottom of a pile. Also, be sure that any compost bins or pens have perforated sides.

Once the pile is built, you can try poking holes in numerous places with poles or branches to increase aeration — although I've never noticed that this technique made much difference. You can try using a "compost aerator," a pole with a flap like a toggle bolt that opens up when you pull it up out of your pile (available from garden supply companies). I've never used one myself. Or you can just break down and use the age-old method of adding oxygen to a pile: turning it. Periodically, take a garden fork and turn the pile — upside down and inside out — over on an adjacent spot.

Water. A compost pile needs moisture to cure. However, too much water will drown out the air and stop the process. The ideal heap, then, is damp but not soggy.

Mass. As pointed out earlier, a compost pile needs to have at least a cubic yard of bulk to heat up properly. And the bigger the better — up to a point. A pile can hardly be too long or wide, but one that is too tall (say over five feet high) may mash down and squeeze out air.

Beneficial microorganisms. These are the guys who actually do all the work. You can buy beneficial bacteria packets to inoculate your compost, but these little fellows are pretty much everywhere and will thrive if you give them an environment they like. One simple way to inoculate your piles for free is to occasionally sprinkle some good garden soil — or compost from a previous pile — on the one you're constructing.

If your pile doesn't heat up, something's wrong.  

Putting It All Together

Now that you know the six essential ingredients of a good compost pile, you need to know how to combine them. The basic technique is simply to alternate layers of nitrogenous and carbonaceous materials. If your pile is all carbon or all nitrogen, your bacteria's diet will be too far out of whack for them to do their job.

The ideal carbon-to-nitrogen ratio is about 25 to 1, but you'd need all sorts of time and charts to figure out how to achieve that precise ratio out of the materials you may have on hand. It's easier — and perfectly effective — to just take some ingredients from the carbon list and some from the nitrogen list and layer them, experimenting with proportions until you find what works for you.

In a nutshell, then: 1) Lay down some stalky material, preferably on bare soil you have forked up some to allow easier passage for bacteria and earthworms. 2) Fork on a layer of carbonaceous material. 3) Fork on a layer of nitrogenous matter. Each layer — N or C — should be about two to eight inches thick. And fluff it up as you add it to promote airflow. 4) Repeat steps 2 and 3 until you've finished building your pile. Sprinkle on a spadeful or two of soil or cured compost occasionally, and if your materials seem dry, spray on some water periodically as you work. 5) Cover the pile with a waterproof tarp to protect it.

I mentioned that you'll have to experiment to find the best ratio of materials for you. One of my "old reliable" combinations, if you'd like to try it, is alternating in a 5-5-2 pattern: a five-inch layer of green matter, a five-inch layer of dry matter, and a two-inch layer of manure. But — contrary to some opinions — good compost piles can be made with all vegetative matter and no manure. Just make sure you have enough nitrogen (here's where something like blood meal or human urine is invaluable).

If It Didn't Work

If all goes well, in about four or five days the interior of your compost pile should have heated up. Indeed, before long a hand poked inside the heap will get uncomfortably hot.

If that happens, congratulations! Your compost is cooking! If your pile doesn't heat up, something's wrong. First check to see if the pile is too wet or too dry. If it's too soggy, turn it, adding more dry material as you do. If it's too dry, wet it.

Assuming the pile is properly moistened and isn't too compressed for good air circulation, your problem is that the compost mixture needs more nitrogen . Turn the pile, incorporating more nitrogenous material as you do so.

You may have a different problem — namely, the cooking mound will smell like ammonia. In that case, you've got too much nitrogen. So turn the pile, adding more carbonaceous matter.

Fast, Medium, or Slow Composting

There's one last step to making compost: turning the pile. And here you have some choices. If you want to get your compost quickly, you'll turn the pile every time its most intense heat (104 degrees to 170 degrees Fahrenheit) starts to drop — about every three to five days. That will add more oxygen and kick up the process. Keep that up and you should have finished compost in two months or less. If all the ingredients have been finely shredded, thinly layered, and turned every three days, it's even possible to make usable compost in two weeks!

If you want your compost in a medium amount of time, turn the pile approximately six weeks after you make it and again six weeks later. Your humus should be ready four to six months after you started it.

And if you're long on patience and short on turning time, just leave the mound alone. Such a slow pile should be ready to use after a year (or even a little longer).

Time is not the only consideration here — there are raging debates about whether "quick" or "slow" compost is better. Since quick-cured piles get well above the pathogen-killing temperature of 140 degrees Fahrenheit, they're the way to go if you want to compost diseased materials (or kill weed seeds).

On the other hand, slow-pile advocates claim that cold-cured compost (which cooks at around 100 degrees Fahrenheit) retains more nutrients.

So relax, dig in, and don't be afraid to experiment. Whichever way you compost, you'll be making the best soil builder your garden could have. You'll also be participating in the light cycle that connects all life on this planet-plant, animal, and even human. As Leandre Poisson has pointed out, we ourselves are "light's ultimate art."


The Rodale Guide to Composting, $14.95 postpaid from Rodale Press, Emmaus, PA.

Fertility Without Fertilizers, by Lawrence D. Hills, Henry Doubleday Research Associates. Out of print.

Let It Rot, by Stu Campbell, $7.95 postpaid from Storey Communications, Inc., Pownal, VT.