European Union Protects Bees but U.S. Continues to Allow Neonicotinoid Pesticides

Scientific evidence linking neonicotinoid pesticides to bee deaths is extensive, and the European Union has recently voted to ban the poisonous substance for two years.


| July 16, 2013



Bee with purple flower

The EU ban came after the European Commission proposed the suspension in response to a report by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) in January that determined that three neonicotinoids – thiamethoxam, clothianidin and imidacloprid – posed an unnacceptable risk to bees.


Photo by Fotolia/claireliz

A press release from Natural Resources Defense Council.

The scientific evidence against the neonicotinoid pesticides (neonics) is stacking up like so many dead and dying bees. And, not just bees - turns out that our little aquatic invertebrate buddies are also harmed, other beneficial insects are harmed, and birds that eat insects are harmed.(see MotherJones story here and American Bird Conservancy report here)

We are very pleased that the European Union has recently voted to ban the neonics for two years (April, 2013 - see report in The Guardian here). The EU decision – supported by 15 of the 27 EU nations – was based on strong scientific evidence showing harm. A French study published in the top journal Science reported an increase in bee foragers that fail to return to the hive following low-dose exposure to Thiamethoxam (made by Syngenta). A British study also published in Science reported a severe loss of queen bees in hives exposed to low doses of Imidacloprid (made by Bayer). (A very good fact sheet on the hazards of Imidacloprid is here)

The EU ban came after the European Commission proposed the suspension in response to a report by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) in January that determined that three neonicotinoids – thiamethoxam, clothianidin and imidacloprid – posed an unnacceptable risk to bees. With the EU vote, now all three will be banned from use for two years on flowering crops such as corn, oilseed rape and sunflowers. (see report on Yale Enviro360 here)

Thanks to a carefully documented report by Corporate Europe Observatory, we have evidence that the EU decision to ban the neonics came despite intense lobbying and interference by Bayer and Syngenta who make and sell the chemicals. In defense of their poisons, these corporations sent letters to high-level government officials blaming the bee deaths on misuse of the chemicals by farmers. They also claimed it was only “a small group activists and hobby beekeepers” that were fueling the movement to ban the insecticides. And, they begged for more time to study the problem while allowing the pesticides continued use, saying it was necessary to avoid “wrong conclusions from a rushed process that could have disastrous implications for agriculture and ironically for bee health”. Hardest to swallow was the claim by Syngenta that “independent analysis” – for which it failed to provide any citations, references, or documentation – showed that banning the neonic pesticides would result in significant damage to European agriculture. (All these industry letters are documented by Corporate Europe here)

A report just released by the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on Honey Bee Health finds that pesticides may be part of the problem, including both the pyrethroid and neonicotinoid classes of pesticides. Both of these classes of pesticides were developed and promoted as reduced-risk replacements for the war-era organophoshate pesticides that were not only deadly to bees and other wildlife, but also highly toxic to people. However, emerging science is proving that these replacement chemicals pose significant risks of harm to bees and beneficial insects, and therefore ultimately to agriculture and our ability to grow our own food. Unfortunately, the USDA/EPA report recommendations are mainly limited to recommendations about best management practices and technical advancements for applying pesticides to reduce dust, etc. The report is conspicuously silent on reducing the overall use of bee-killing pesticides, that is, on recommendations that would reduce the overall sales and profits for chemical makers.

tgrbts
7/30/2013 9:32:43 AM

I appreciate the knowledge, and I'm not here for the politicals either, but I know they play a part.  I'm saddened by the turn of our society.  Even my children don't seem to "get" it.  I garden but they don't get involved.  I believe at some point, there will be half a world of people who can not take care of themselves.  While I strive to become self sufficient I can't even find a job, let alone a job that will pay me enough to buy land that I can become self sufficient on.  and now with the insurance, how will I ever pay that, I can't get a job.    It frustrates me to see articles about a couple who has retired now, and is living the 'sustainable life' they bought on their pensions who they earned by living the rat race.  All the time they were comuting to the city to work they added to the global warming and worked for companies that hurt the earth.   Most of America seems more interested in making money for themselves than preserving the earth for their grand children.  Spray our food, kill off endangered species, I don't understand how they can't see that, once it's gone, it's gone forever.  sorry I'm off my soapbox.  If we don't have the bees we don't eat.


rob73
7/30/2013 7:34:43 AM

EPA is just as useless as any other goverment organaztion.  Nothing will be done as usual.


gladdrial
7/29/2013 2:17:29 PM

This is not meant against any political stance, just take all the bees away and then see where we stand.

I was raised a a Midwest Farm and know how important these little creatures are to Our farm Communities,

Ask any Farmers of their importance.


gladdrial
7/29/2013 2:13:09 PM

What is wrong with our Country? Don't these so called elites understand just plain common sense or What!

WE NEED BEES you Morons~!


ballyshannon
7/29/2013 1:57:51 PM

I heartily agree with the conclusions, but as I've said before, I want Mother Earth to give me advice on vegetables, livestock and building stuff.  I get twenty newsletters on political concerns, including NRDC, and I keep wanting your information to be more homey and nurturing.  Or, you could write about the bee situation on your own without the political slant.






dairy goat

MOTHER EARTH NEWS FAIR

Aug. 5-6, 2017
Albany, Ore.

Discover a dazzling array of workshops and lectures designed to get you further down the path to independence and self-reliance.

LEARN MORE