Safe ... or Sorry? Look-alikes in Nature

Here’s how to distinguish some of nature’s harmless and potentially harmful look-alikes.
By Terry Krautwurst
June/July 2007
Add to My MSN

One way to distinguish honeybees from look-alikes is to look at their antennae, which, for honeybees, are longer than their heads.  
DWIGHT KUHN
Slideshow


Content Tools

Related Content

Ditch the Itch: Get Rid of Poison Ivy Plants

Get rid of poison ivy plants in your yard by following these instructions. Just don’t forget to prot...

How Can I Remove Poison Ivy Vines From a Tree?

Killing poison ivy can be tricky — especially if it’s entwined in a tree near your house. But you ca...

Ground Operations

America needs one million new farmers. Veterans want the job.

Earth Gauge Tip of the Week: Walk Wisely in the Woods

How to avoid contacting poison ivy and poison oak.

The trail I was hiking skirted a popular picnic area, and as I passed a family having lunch the mother suddenly shrieked: “Sara! Get down from that fence! It’s covered with poison ivy!” The little girl, about 5 years old, leapt to the ground and stared at the accused leafy monster, her eyes wide with alarm.

I winced. Clearly the vine curling over the fence wasn’t poison ivy, but Virginia creeper, a somewhat similar-looking — and entirely harmless — plant. A case of mistaken identity had needlessly frightened the youngster and sullied a carefree family outing. Ironically, as I glanced at the scene again, the mother was standing, open-sandaled, in a patch of actual poison ivy.

There are many look-alikes in nature, and while most pose little urgency, it’s important to know how to tell hazardous flora and fauna from similar-looking safe species. In most cases, the knowledge simply allows you to enjoy the outdoors more fully, without worry; in others, it can make the difference between safety and personal risk.

Bees & Wasps vs. Flower Flies

 

Bzzzzt! Watch out for that fuzzy, yellow-and-black striped ... fly? A variety of harmless insects fool bug-gobbling predators by wearing the same watch-out-I-sting gang colors as bees or wasps. The most common are syrphid (or flower) flies, a large family of imposters that are startlingly convincing. But the truth is, they don’t have stingers and couldn’t hurt a ... well, you know.

Many syrphids buzz just like their ouch-instigating counterparts, and can be alarmingly bold. The yellowjacket hover fly has a habit of buzzing up to a person and hovering there for a moment, as if to say, “Boo!” At least a dozen other flower flies resemble yellowjackets, while many others mimic honeybees, bumblebees, carpenter bees and all manner of wasps.

Syrphid flies are important pollinators, and the larvae of many species are voracious predators of plant-sucking aphids. The next time a beelike insect buzzes at you, don’t be too quick to hit the panic button.

Bee or Wasp 

Syrphid Fly 

Four wings

Two wings

At rest, wings folded over back

At rest, wings held slightly to the sides

Waist distinctly pinched (wasp only)

Waist not distinctly pinched

Antennae longer than head

Antennae stubby, shorter than head

Flight: straight, smooth, point-to-point; poor hoverers 

Flight: angular, zoom-stop-zoom, like a hummingbird; excellent hoverers


Poison Ivy vs. Look-alikes

They are the terrible trio of American flora: poison sumac, oak and ivy. Fortunately, the former is limited to swampy terrain in the East and Midwest. And though poison oak is common along the West Coast and in sandy soils in the lower East and Midwest, its oaklike leaves and typically shrublike posture are comparatively easy to spot.

Poison ivy, though, hides. It’s not just the mosquito of the botanic world; it’s the chameleon. It can be a vine, a shrub or treelike. It creeps, climbs and stands on its own. Its leaves can be green, yellow or red; oval or lance-shaped; toothed, lobed or smooth-edged; light or dark; shiny or dull. Botanists can’t even agree on how many poison ivy species exist. Most agree there are two main kinds of poison ivy; the eastern type tends to climb as a vine and the western tends to be shrubby — but neither is consistent. Plus, the plant often grows near and intermingles with look-alikes. We’ve all heard the old saw, “Leaves of three, leave it be,” and poison ivy does indeed bear leaves in groups of three. But so do many innocent plants, such as wild strawberry, jack-in-the-pulpit, blackberry, raspberry, box elder and hog-peanut. You’d have to stay home to steer clear of them all.

Other plants only vaguely resemble poison ivy, but share similar growth habits. Virginia creeper has five leaves, not three, and those leaves are distinctly toothed, while poison ivy’s are not. But like poison ivy, its spring greenery is triangular and glossy; it climbs fences and trees as a twining vine, and in the fall its foliage changes from green to scarlet. How, then, can you avoid poison ivy? First, learn to recognize the plant in all its forms. But beyond that, keep a wary eye out not only for the plant itself, but also for signs that it may be hiding nearby (see list, below).

Where Poison Ivy May Lurk 

Sunny areas in open woods and along trails and field edges

Disturbed soils (pathways, campgrounds, etc.)

Presence of common companion plants: Virginia creeper, jewelweed, hog-peanut


Venomous or Not?

In the United States, there are two groups of venomous snakes: pit vipers, which include rattlesnakes, copperheads and cottonmouths, and coral snakes, which are comparatively rare.

Pit vipers get their name from the tiny, heat-sensing (and thus prey-detecting) pit located on each side of the head, between the eye and nostril. Obviously, if you see a snake with rattles you know it’s venomous. This makes identifying a dangerous snake easier in the West, where rattlesnakes are the only pit vipers. (Keep in mind, however, that rattlesnakes can lose their rattles.)

In the eastern United States, rattle-less cottonmouths and copperheads complicate matters. Both bear markings similar to those of many harmless species. To distinguish a pit viper from a look-alike, look (from a distance, ideally using binoculars) for the telltale distinctions listed below. Snakes with large bodies and distinct patterns, such as rat snakes, corn snakes and hog-nosed, are easily misidentified. It’s especially easy to mistake water snakes for a copperhead or cottonmouth; they share physical features and similar habitat.

With copperheads, look at the snake’s pattern. Its hourglass-shaped crossbands are narrow in the center of the back and wide along the sides. On water snakes, they’re the opposite — fattest along the snake’s center and narrow at the sides.

Cottonmouths vary in color from solid brown, black or olive, to patterns of these colors. Body language and behavior can be more important clues for distinguishing them from water snakes. On land, cottonmouths are poor climbers and are more likely to form a tight circular coil on a stump or log just above water level. Water snakes usually hang draped over a branch in a tree or bush. In the water, a cottonmouth swims with its head held well above the water’s surface; water snakes swim totally immersed.

Habitat and range are critical, common-sense considerations, too. Cottonmouths, for instance, inhabit only the South and lower Midwest. Even if you live in one of those regions, you can rest a little easier if you’re well away from the watery habitat they favor. A good field guide will tell you which snakes actually live in your area, and the kinds of places they tend to call home.

 

Pit Viper 

Nonvenomous 

Broad, arrow-shaped head

Elongated oval head

Neck distinctly narrowed

Neck slightly narrowed

Heavy-looking body

Proportionately slender body

Facial pits

No facial pits

Vertical pupil

Round pupil


Compared to pit vipers, coral snakes are relatively small — usually no more than 2 feet long — and mild-mannered. They spend most of their time underground or beneath forest litter, and their primary prey is other snakes. But when coral snakes do bite, they pack a dangerous punch. Members of the same deadly family as cobras, their venom is exceedingly potent.

Fortunately, a coral snake’s bright bands of yellow, red and black make it easy to spot. But you might be looking at one of its harmless near-twins, the scarlet snake and scarlet kingsnake, both of which occupy part of the coral’s southern coastal range, from North Carolina to east Texas.

A simple saying to help tell the snakes apart is, “Red touch yellow, kills a fellow; red touch black, safe for Jack.” The rule of thumb applies for both U.S. species, the eastern coral snake and the Sonoran (or western) coral snake. It’s not always reliable for similar snakes south of the border, though. And in the Sonoran coral’s range, south-central Arizona to southwestern New Mexico, nonvenomous shovel-nosed snakes wear adjacent red and yellow bands, too.

Scientists aren’t sure whether the scarlets are mimicking the coral, or the other way around. For years they thought the impostors had adapted the coral’s colorful bands as a survival strategy. Predators that learned the hard way to avoid coral snakes would avoid them, too. But wait a minute: a coral snake’s bite is not a learning experience. Almost invariably, the victim dies. Perhaps, instead, the coral snake has taken on the harmless snakes’ color as a sort of sheep’s clothing.

For safety’s sake, steer clear of all brightly banded species wherever corals roam.

Coral or Scarlet Snake? 

• Red and yellow bands touch: coral snake

• Red and yellow bands don’t touch: harmless scarlet snake, or a scarlet kingsnake or another milk snake


Grizzly vs. Black Bears

In the West, where black and grizzly bears share habitat, knowing one from the other is serious business. Black bears have evolved a flight response to danger. But grizzlies are programmed to fight — offense is their defense. In a surprise encounter with a black bear, most experts advise to stand your ground and, if necessary, shout and wave your arms to scare it away. But if it’s a grizzly, they suggest, that behavior might provoke an attack. Instead act nonthreatening. Avoid eye contact and back away slowly.

But figuring out which bear you’re dealing with can be difficult. Coat color isn’t a reliable distinction, because some grizzlies can have near-black fur, and many western black bears wear brownish fur akin to that of lighter-colored grizzlies. There are distinctive differences between the two species, but no one feature is defining. You have to put together all the clues (see the list below) to reach a reasonable conclusion.

Experts advise looking at the head first — the relative size of ears, the facial profile, the shape. Remember, too, that the safest strategy is to avoid bears, period. Like all wild animals, black bears and grizzly bears are unpredictable. They also are big, fast, strong and armed — tooth and claw. When it comes to bears, consider them all members of a single species: Respectimus maximus.

 

Grizzly Bear 

Black Bear 

Round face

Oval face

Short ears

Proportionately longer ears

Concave facial profile

Straight facial profile

Shoulder hump

Shoulder hump absent or less pronounced

Body slopes downward; rump lower than shoulder

Body tilts upward; rump higher than shoulders

Long claws

Short claws

Neck ruff present in spring and fall

No neck ruff


Familiarity Is the Key

Knowing what to look for — and what not to worry about — is the key to distinguishing safe from potentially harmful species. Studying field guides is a great way to familiarize yourself with the safe-or-sorry plants and insects in your area. Nature centers and zoos offer you an opportunity to get to know animals such as snakes and bears safely. But ultimately, of course, the best teacher of all is experience in the outdoors. The more time you spend outside and the more familiar you become with the flora and fauna around you, the more you can enjoy the natural world.


 


Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next






Post a comment below.

 








Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 66% Off the Cover Price

First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Lighten the Strain on the Earth and Your Budget

MOTHER EARTH NEWS is the guide to living — as one reader stated — “with little money and abundant happiness.” Every issue is an invaluable guide to leading a more sustainable life, covering ideas from fighting rising energy costs and protecting the environment to avoiding unnecessary spending on processed food. You’ll find tips for slashing heating bills; growing fresh, natural produce at home; and more. MOTHER EARTH NEWS helps you cut costs without sacrificing modern luxuries.

At MOTHER EARTH NEWS, we are dedicated to conserving our planet’s natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. That’s why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.00 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.00 for 6 issues.