Water Without Work


August/September 2006

The WaterMatic is just one of more than a dozen specialized product lines offered by Ritchie Industries. It’s suitable for up to 40 cattle or horses, and goats like it, too.
RITCHIE INDUSTRIES
Slideshow


Content Tools

Related Content

Can I Afford to Make my House Energy Efficient?

The Database of State Incentives for Renewables & Efficiency (DSIRE) provides state-by-state inf...

Eating Cicadas and Building a Porch

Eating cicadas, building a porch, and hauling lumber for said porch all in the same week with severa...

Why Do You Value Your Heritage Breed Livestock?

We know why we love heritage breed livestock, but why do you?

Energy-Efficient Products for Your Home

Information about energy-efficient washing machines and cellular window shades. These energy-efficie...

Issue #217 August/September 2006
By Bryan Welch

These automatic livestock waterers use no energy and save a lot of time.

Author and “Contrary Farmer” Gene Logsdon says farmers should design their grass-based livestock farms so they can spend as much time as possible sipping lemonade and watching the animals graze. If your animals graze most or all of the year on pasture, and if you put out big bales when you feed them hay, you’ll have many days without any feeding chores. But your critters can’t do without water, the most important nutrient for livestock. So, in the summer, you fill troughs every day. And in the winter, you head out every day — maybe twice — to break up the ice. We’ve broken a few axe handles doing that.

Technology can help — several companies build clever alternatives to the daily drudgery of supplying water to your animals. These “automatic waterers” essentially are appliances hooked into water supply lines that can provide a reliable water source for your animals without your daily attention.

To evaluate the benefits these devices can offer, we installed five automatic waterers from several companies and ran them through four seasons with our cattle, goats and sheep. There are “cup waterers” and other designs intended for installation in a barn, but for this article we concentrated on waterers designed for installation on a concrete pad in a pasture. We didn’t want to use electricity, so we looked at only “energy-free” models, designed to resist freezing without electricity.
Many other designs exist, however. Watering systems are available in a wide range of materials and sizes for installation indoors or outdoors. They’re all basically the same: A drinking reservoir fills automatically when a valve is triggered by declining water level. However, designers have taken several approaches to the challenge of providing clean water reliably while minimizing evaporation in summer and freezing in winter. Consequently, some specialized terms come into the conversation.

“Energy efficient” generally means the unit is insulated heavily and uses a low-drain electric heating system. “Energy free” generally means no electricity is required to operate the waterer or prevent freezing, although some manufacturers say supplemental heat may be necessary to prevent freezing in extended periods of extreme cold. Manufacturers also say energy-free models are more likely to freeze if they aren’t used by at least a certain minimum number of animals. There also are “continuous-flow” models that prevent freezing by running water continuously through the container, with the surplus flowing into a drainage sump.

To discourage algae and mosquitoes, many outdoor livestock waterers have some sort of seal — a lid or floating cap — that the animal pushes aside to drink. All waterers, including energy-free units, require a pressurized water supply, and protection from wind helps minimize evaporation and freezing.

Plan for Efficiency

Before you decide to put waterers in your pasture, plan carefully, and account for your installation costs. The waterers themselves are relatively inexpensive, usually less than $700 or so — they’re easy to justify when you figure that you won’t need to buy any more water tanks, hoses or axe handles.

Installation, on the other hand, may set you back. You’ll need to run water supply lines, buried below your freeze line, to every waterer location, and the installation of the waterers is not straightforward. The water supply comes up through a deep insulated hole, and some of the fittings are unique. If you don’t do trenching and plumbing, you’ll need help from someone who does. Obviously, it’s critical to plan for effective distribution and efficient installation.

To install five waterers scattered around 50 acres, we paid nearly $7,000 for plumbing, pipes and trenching. All told, we spent slightly less than $2,000 per waterer. If we had dug our own trenches, laid our own pipe and done our own plumbing, we could have reduced that cost to less than $900 per unit. And if our pastures came together in a central location, we could have installed a simpler layout for even less.

Factors to Consider

Here are a few questions to help you choose the waterer that is right for you:

What is the smallest number of animals in your pasture at any given time of the year? When the pasture is empty, you can simply turn off and drain the waterer (don’t forget to install individual shutoff valves on the lines to each unit). But if you keep a couple of bulls or billy goats in a winter pasture by themselves, they may not drink often enough to prevent an energy-free unit from freezing. Most energy-free units are designed for optimal loads of 25 to 50 animals.

(For more information on the average amount of water needed by your livestock in both summer and winter, see "Water Consumption of Pastured Livestock." — Mother)

How cold is your climate? We found that some energy-free models, when adjusted properly, stayed unfrozen through the Kansas winter, even with just a few animals on them. Temperatures hovered around 20 degrees for a week or so, and our coldest stretch was four days with lows between minus 7 and 7 degrees. However, the waterers got a little frosty, and we figure they would have frozen in colder temperatures.

How easy is it to check your water? Livestock owners know what it feels like to lie in bed fretting about whether their animals have water. We’ve all driven away from the house wondering whether we should have stopped to check the troughs. Some automatic waterers have visible floats that are a different color from the rest of the appliance, making it easy to see whether there’s a sufficient amount of water in the reservoir, even from half a mile away.

Ease into Automatic Watering

If you notice that your neighbors have installed waterers, ask them about the advantages and disadvantages of the model they chose.

You might consider installing just one unit in a single pasture for the first winter to get a sense of its functionality. Or go the safer, more expensive route, and install waterers with electric heating elements. Of course, you’ll pay to install electric wiring and for the electricity. And the heater is one more thing that can malfunction; you might not notice an improperly adjusted thermostat and end up paying for heat year-round.

When severe cold is predicted, you may get worried about an energy-free waterer freezing. An inexpensive trough-heating element will work with most models, if the waterer is close enough to an electrical outlet. Just place the heater in your waterer and plug it into an extension cord. The cord is a nuisance, but you can unplug and remove it easily when not in use.

Outstanding in the Field

The most remarkable units we tried out were the “MiraFount” waterers from Miraco. They performed perfectly throughout the Kansas winter, even with minimal animal loads (a ram, two buck goats and a mule). One did freeze when we adjusted the water level too low and allowed the spherical water cap to float below the level of its opening. Aside from that, the MiraFounts were perfectly maintenance-free. Their round, blue, floating water caps are visible against their black housings from far away, so if you have a clear line of sight, you can check your reservoirs from indoors — a benefit we did not anticipate. The spherical caps also did a good job of preventing ice from forming in the reservoir. Miraco offers waterers in a wide range of styles and sizes, including models for poultry and pets.

On the farm, anything that prevents worry and drudgery increases your ability to work effectively with your animals — and to enjoy your lifestyle. Our automatic waterers definitely have enhanced our pleasure in livestock farming. Now, we find ourselves spending more time sipping lemonade and watching the animals graze — and drink.

DIY Solar-powered Livestock Waterer

(Reader Gene Christensen, of Jordan, Mont., sent in this letter and photo describing his ingenious homemade watering system. For more information, contact him at ivan@midrivers.com. — Mother)

My system has a reservoir buried in the ground that holds water until it is needed. On top of it is a culvert, set vertically, with the drinking basin on top. Solar panels power a submersible pump that sends water up to the drinking basin. A motion sensor turns the pump on when an animal comes to drink and turns the pump off when the animal leaves. Holes in the drinking basin let excess water return to the underground reservoir. A float valve controls flow from the underground water line to keep the reservoir full. A battery powers the waterer at night. The setup cost me about $3,100.

I live in Montana, so I put the water line and reservoir 8 feet down to get below the frost line. They would not need to be buried that deep in warmer climates. The water temperature is 55 degrees most of the year, which is cool in summer and warm in winter. Because the water drains down to the underground reservoir, there is no standing water, so I have no problems with algae or mosquitoes, and I don’t have to chip ice in winter.

My dogs have learned to use the waterer and have a wonderful time with it. I think goats and sheep could learn to use it as well, so it could be used for all kinds of livestock.

Sources for Livestock Waterers

Livestock watering equipment is made of plastic, concrete, steel or other materials. Sizes range from single-animal bowls to feedlot troughs. Some manufacturers offer specialized designs for horses, cattle, sheep, hogs or mixed groups. Several also make poultry waterers. Prices do not include shipping and handling.

MiraFount Energy-Free Waterers
Available in seven models; company also makes many electric waterers.
$85 – $1,009
Miraco Livestock Water Systems: P.O. Box 686, Grinnell, IA 50112
(800) 541-7866

Ritchie Waterers
Many models, some energy efficient, in a dozen product lines
$198 – $575
Ritchie Industries: P.O. Box 730, Conrad, IA 50621
(800) 747-0222

SPI Livestock Waterers
Several models, some energy free
$260 – $715
SPI Industries: P.O. Box 10, Shallow Lake, Ontario N0H 2K0, Canada
(800) 269-6533

Bohlmann Waterers
Made of concrete; many models in a wide size range.
$300 – $1,000
Bohlmann: P.O. Box 369,Denison, IA 51442
(800) 325-2380

Brower Energy-Free Livestock Waterers
Available in several models; company also makes electric waterers
$88 – $620
Hawkeye Steel Products: P.O. Box 2000, Houghton, IA 52631
(800) 553-1791

Cancrete Waterers
Concrete bowls with stainless steel components
$700 – $750
Advanced Agri-Direct: P.O. Box 298, Thorsby, Alberta T0C 2P0, Canada
(866) 789-3336

Equuspring Waterers
Primarily for horses; models for stall or pasture.
$114 – $643
Equuspring: 5333 Industrial Drive, Huntington Beach, CA 92649
(877) 635-6289

Franklin Waterers
Three energy-efficient models and 12 standard models
$319 – $500
Franklin Industries: P.O. Box 271, Monticello, IA 52310-0271
(800) 422-3561

Frostfree Nosepumps
No power needed for pumping or heat; livestock pump their own water
$1,075; lids and insulation kits extra
Frostfree Nosepumps: P.O. Box 675, Rimbey, Alberta T0C 2J0, Canada
(866) 843-6744

Hoskins Waterers
Numerous models for cattle, horses, sheep, hogs
$300 – $1,000
Hoskins Manufacturing Co.: P.O. Box 101, Hoskins, NE 68740
(800) 658-4020

HW Brand
Numerous models, some energy-free
$300 – $535
Hutchison Western: P.O. Box 1158; Adams City, CO 80022
(800) 525-0121

The Jug Waterer
One-, two-, and four-bowl models, unheated/heated
$500 – $910
Bakko Industries: 28958 198th Ave., Glenwood, MN 56334
(800) 584-6675

Nelson Livestock Waterers
Eight models, unheated/heated
$200 – $500
Nelson Manufacturing Co.: P.O. Box 636, Cedar Rapids, IA 52406
(888) 844-6606

Pride of the Farm Polar-Max Drinkers
Energy-free; the company also makes electric models
$88 – $1,080
Hawkeye Steel Products: P.O. Box 2000, Houghton, IA 52631
(800) 553-1791

Suntanks
Solar collectors prevent freezing
$379 – $559
Amesco: P.O. Box 281, Santa Clara, UT 84765
(435) 656-0229

Trojan Automatic Waterers
Available in six models
$28 – $257
Trojan Specialty Products: P.O. Box 1735; Dodge City, KS 67801
(800) 279-1770

Water Consumption of Pastured Livestock

Animals on pasture get some moisture from the water contained in grass, but they need sufficient, reliable supplies of clean water to grow and remain healthy. Factors that affect water consumption include weather conditions, diet, activity level and access. The animals’ size and type are important, and physical condition (pregnancy, rapid growth, lactation) also can make a big difference in water requirements.

As a rough guide to how much water you should provide to your livestock, the following table shows typical consumption in winter and summer.

Gallons per day per head
   
Winter
Summer
Dairy cattle
17
21
Beef cattle
7
12
Cow-calf pairs
11
15
Young cattle
7
10
Horses
8
12
Sheep/goats
1
3
Swine
3
5
Chickens (100 birds)
8
10
Turkeys (100 birds)
10
15

Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next






Post a comment below.

 








Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 66% Off the Cover Price

First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Lighten the Strain on the Earth and Your Budget

MOTHER EARTH NEWS is the guide to living — as one reader stated — “with little money and abundant happiness.” Every issue is an invaluable guide to leading a more sustainable life, covering ideas from fighting rising energy costs and protecting the environment to avoiding unnecessary spending on processed food. You’ll find tips for slashing heating bills; growing fresh, natural produce at home; and more. MOTHER EARTH NEWS helps you cut costs without sacrificing modern luxuries.

At MOTHER EARTH NEWS, we are dedicated to conserving our planet’s natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. That’s why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.00 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.00 for 6 issues.