Organic Gardening

Get dirty, have fun and grow more food with great gardening tips from real-life gardeners.

Add to My MSN

New York Says No to Burning Leaves

10/20/2009 2:03:28 PM





Like most gardeners, this time of year I drive slow when passing certain houses, which are known sources of clean bagged leaves. I can’t get enough leaves for composting and mulching, so why would anyone want to burn them? I know the answer – some folks just plain like to do it – but that doesn’t justify the air pollution load leaf burning releases into the atmosphere. The state of New York agrees! This month, New York joined a growing list of states where burning leaves is a crime. Communities like Muskegon County, MI, banned leaf burning back in 1973. Delaware and several other states followed suit in the mid-1990’s.

Fewer leaves being burned should play out as more being composted, but where will they rot? Recession-related budget cuts have reduced or eliminated leaf composting programs from Portland, OR to Brunswick, OH. Cities like Roanoke, VA will pick up only bagged leaves this year, with biodegradable paper leaf bags preferred. In Woodbridge, NJ, you can get paper leaf bags for free.

In some areas, the cost of collecting leaves with a vacuum truck runs as high as $100 per household, which makes me think I may be in the wrong business. Then again, in a society where money seems to talk loudest, maybe a big price tag on leaf collection is what it will take to get more people composting. When the city of Niagara Falls, ON weighed the financial costs vs. environmental benefits of composting yard waste, they came up with a negative $13.53 per ton. If everyone composted their leaves, those benefits would run even higher.

But back to burn bans, which are making the air easier to breathe in Moline, IL and thousands of other towns this fall. Leaf burning is a local issue that impacts people on a neighborhood level. I’m all for a no-leaf-burn nation, but then I’m a collector with my own interests at stake. Where do you stand?

Contributing editor Barbara Pleasant is coauthor of The Complete Compost Gardening Guide, which recently won a Silver Award of Achievement in writing from the Garden Writers Association.


Content Tools

Post a comment below.


11/10/2013 5:34:27 PM
I compost nearly all yard waste except for limbs and they go in the patio burner on chilly evenings. On the other hand, government getting in people's business is never a good thing. Before getting all wound up and crying about the smoke and all, remember, that is the same government that calls compost / mulch a trash pile and stacked firewood a brush pile. Been there! The smart solution would be to talk to neighbors that burn and have them rake the leaves into a heap for you and your fellow composters to collect. Screw big brother!

Subscribe Today!

Pay Now & Save 67% Off the Cover Price

(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here