The Often Underrated Compressed Air Gun

For homesteaders who want most of the advantages of firearms without owning an actual firearm, the compressed air gun is a viable alternative.
By Jim Carmichel
May/June 1981
Add to My MSN

The spring-piston air rifle is a common type of compressed air gun.
ILLUSTRATION: OUTDOOR LIFE STAFF
Slideshow


Content Tools

Related Content

A Sweet Time of the Year

Cam and Michelle enjoy a visit to their neighbour's "sugar shack" during maple syrup season!

American Airlines Scores High On Newsweek's Green Rankings List

American Airlines is the greenest U.S. airline for the third consecutive year in Newsweek's Green Ra...

Cold, Colder, Coldest: Which Vegetables Overwinter in the Garden?

Some crops survived the cold temperatures while others died. Which ones are most reliable for winter...

Springtime In The Mountains

How we determine springtime at 9,759 feet elevation.

All the folks here at MOTHER EARTH NEWS were pleased with the response generated by Gary Kent's article, "Homestead Firearms".  Many readers are interested in having a practical gun on hand to protect their livestock and homes, and occasionally put food on the table, and those readers who aren't interested in owning such weapons don't begrudge others the right to do so.  

Furthermore, a good number of the letters received here asked for more information on firearm alternatives. Well, it would be hard to imagine a more practical tool for such tasks as controlling pests, repelling small predators and putting meat in the homestead freezer than the compressed air gun. Such firearms are often surprisingly powerful (and, therefore, must be handled with the same respect as "real" guns), quite accurate, easy to maintain and extremely inexpensive to shoot. For a total spare-parts-and-ammunition investment of well under $200, you'll be able to add a rabbit to the pot, as times demand, for years to come!  

Spring-Piston Gun

The most common air gun mechanism is the so-called spring-piston type used in millions of American BB guns. Since this basic mechanism is the power source of our simplest, least expensive air guns, one might conclude that it is relatively inefficient. Such is not the case. Essentially the same mechanism is used in the most expensive, most accurate and most powerful air guns. 

In simplest terms, a spring-piston gun is powered by a spring-powered piston that's contained in a closely fitted, tube-like chamber. This chamber serves as the gun's receiver, which is mounted in the stock with the barrel attached to one end and the firing mechanism attached to the other. When the gun is cocked, the piston is forced to the rear of the chamber, where it is held in place by a catch, or sear, linked to the trigger. At this point the mainspring is compressed to full tension.

When the trigger is pulled, the powerful mainspring slams the piston through the chamber, driving and compressing the air in front of it. This body of air escapes through the barrel, driving the projectile.

The relative projectile velocity of a spring-piston air gun is determined by a number of factors, but velocity is mainly a function of the speed and power of the piston and the volume of air displaced. Other factors are the weight and size of the pellet, and the amount of air leakage which occurs around the projectile and piston. Naturally, a projectile which efficiently seals the bore, and a close (but not tight) piston-to-chamber fit are more efficient than tolerances that permit air blowby.

For illustration, look inside a more or less typical Daisy BB gun. When the gun is cocked, the piston is levered back against the spring, which in turn is "loaded" to a force equal to about 60 pounds. When the trigger is pulled, the spring drives the piston forward in the chamber for a distance of slightly over 2 inches.

In everyday ballistic terms, the piston velocity tops out at about 41 feet per second. Why then, you may ask, does the BB projectile have a muzzle velocity of over 300 fps? First of all, the piston and spring are not pushing the BB itself, but rather a column of air. Since this moving column of air can escape only through the small hole in the barrel, it obeys the laws of gas dynamics and speeds up in order to move its volume out of the chamber. This means that the air in the barrel moves faster than the air immediately ahead of the piston. This is what gives the BB its first big push. The second kick is supplied by the air compressed in the chamber.

At first the BB doesn't want to move (because of its inertia), causing the air to "pile up" behind it and become compressed. In fact, the piston has traveled a half-inch before the BB moves at all. This means that the air in the chamber is being compressed, eventually reaching a pressure greater than 300 pounds per square inch! Even after the piston stops, this compressed air continues driving and accelerating the BB. At the moment the piston stops its forward motion, the BB has a velocity of some 175 fps and has traveled less than 2 inches up the barrel. At this point the compressed air, which is near its peak, takes over and accelerates the BB to about 300 fps during its next 3 inches of travel. As the BB moves up the barrel, it reaches a velocity of about 330 fps.

Naturally, different makes and models of spring-piston guns generate different pressures and velocities.

When air is compressed, heat is generated, and this brings about a peculiar side effect when we shoot air guns. When the chamber pressure in our Red Ryder carbine is at its peak, the internal temperature soars to a momentary high of 620°F. This temperature can ignite residual oil in the chamber, which accounts for the smoke we sometimes see coming from the muzzle and for the characteristic smoky smell we detect when shooting air guns. Occasionally, when too much oil is pumped into an air gun barrel (either accidentally or on purpose), the resulting diesel effect, or oil explosion, raises chamber pressures and velocities well above normal. This explains the harsh jolt you may sometimes feel when shooting a freshly oiled air gun and also explains why it is best to lubricate with special nonflashing oils. Dieseling is hard on guns.

The spring-piston system is used in a wide assortment of makes, models, and styles of air guns. The most common cocking arrangement, of course, is the under-lever arrangement used on millions of BB guns.

If a more powerful spring is used, a cocking system employing greater leverage is required. Thus the most powerful spring-piston guns are of the barrel-lever variety in which the barrel itself, by means of a toggle linkage, provides the leverage to cock the powerful mainspring. The barrel is hinged at the breech, just ahead of the receiver-cylinder assembly, and pivots downward during the cocking cycle. This exposes the breech end of the barrel for convenient loading and maintenance. In this type of gun, the rear sight is mounted on the barrel where it is fixed in relation to the front sight.

Another high-leverage cocking arrangement features a separate cocking arm located alongside or underneath the cylinder-receiver. This is the system used on the top tournament-grade air guns, such as the Feinwerkbau Model 300 rifle and models 65 and 80 pistols, and it has the accuracy advantage of having the barrel rigidly attached to the receiver assembly. Some side and under-lever makes are loaded by placing the projectile directly into the breech, while others are loaded by means of a ported tumbler which rotates up for loading and then pivots the projectile into barrel alignment.

One of the advantages of spring-piston air guns is their highly uniform shot-to-shot velocity. Just as with powder-burning guns, uniformity of velocity contributes to close grouping. On the other side of the ledger, however, are a couple of problems, inherent in spring-piston guns, which tend to cause accuracy problems. The first of these is the massive sear mechanism required to hold the powerful spring securely in the cocked position. A common by-product is a hard and creepy trigger pull. This is noticeable in inexpensive American-made BB guns, but quite a few expensive European air guns have equally poor trigger pulls. Apparently, the problem can be overcome only by complex, multilever trigger mechanisms which add to the price.

The other disadvantage to accuracy is the very noticeable recoil, or bounce, generated by the powerful spring and piston motion. This is so troublesome to accuracy that top competition models feature special anti-recoil devices. The best of these work so well that the rifles and pistols seem not to move at all when they are fired. Some of these competition guns sell for over $600. 

Pneumatic Gun

Pneumatic air guns are also known as pump-up guns because of the pumping operation necessary to accumulate and compress air in the "air tank" or reservoir. Modern pneumatic air guns made by Benjamin, Crosman, Daisy, Sheridan and Walther generally have compression chambers enclosed in the stock recess beneath the barrel and conveniently close to the breech. 

Operation of the pneumatic system is simple. When the pump handle is pulled out, or extended, it withdraws a piston, or plunger, which works much like a bicycle tire pump. On the out stroke, air enters a cylinder that closely encloses the piston. On the in stroke, the piston forces the trapped air into the compression chamber through a valve which lets air in but not out.

With each stroke of the pump handle, an equal volume of air is pumped into the compression chamber. As the pressure within the chamber increases, it becomes progressively harder to pump in more air. Since heat is produced as air is compressed, the compression chamber becomes noticeably warm.

To fire the gun, another valve at the other end of the cylindrical compression chamber is opened, and the compressed air is vented into the gun's breech. It races up the barrel to drive the projectile. Velocity depends on both the pressure of the air and the volume of air let into the barrel.

This basically simple mechanism is complicated somewhat by the need for a sealed breeching system which must be opened for loading, and by a firing system which opens the exhaust valve. Since this valve is locked in a tightly closed position by high internal pressure, it requires considerable pressure to open it. It's comparable to opening a barn door into a high wind. This is why the pump-up firing mechanism actually knocks the valve open by means of a spring-loaded striker. When you cock a pneumatic gun (usually by opening the breech to load), you are actually withdrawing this rather heavy striker against spring pressure. The fall of the striker accounts for the solid thump you feel when you pull the trigger.

The accuracy potential of the pneumatic or pump-up system is excellent. Two top-rated tournament guns, Walther's LGR rifle and LP3 pistol, are of pneumatic operation. They differ from most pneumatic guns in that they are pumped up by a single stroke of the pump lever and feature virtually motionless firing (valve opening) mechanisms which result in recoilless operation. The Daisy pellet firing models 717 (.17 caliber) and 722 (.22 caliber) pneumatic-style target pistols feature singlestroke charging, as does the Daisy Model 850 pellet/BB rifle. Most pneumatics can be lightly pumped for plinking and target shooting, or they can be pumped to higher velocities for hunting or long-range shooting. This advantage is offset by the physical effort, noise and motion required to pump up the reservoir. 

CO2 Guns

The mechanics of CO2 guns are quite similar to those of pneumatic guns. The principal difference is that the CO2 gas is pre-compressed rather than being compressed in the gun as needed. The exhaust valve, venting, breeching and firing mechanisms of CO2 and pneumatic systems work in such similar fashion that on some models of each by the same manufacturer many parts are interchangeable. In other models of CO2 guns, considerable individuality is apparent. 

Though certain other gases could be used as a power source, carbon dioxide has the physical and chemical advantages of being nonflammable, noncorrosive, odorless, inexpensive and not chemically reactive.

The CO2 in the familiar little seltzer bottle cylinders is compressed into liquid form. When a CO2 cartridge is inserted into the gun and the steel punctured, a certain amount of the liquid CO 2 boils off in gas form and fills the gas reservoir. When a specific amount of gas has boiled off, the resulting vapor pressure keeps the remaining carbon dioxide liquid. This fortunate characteristic, as we shall see, is important to the practical operation of CO2 guns.

When the trigger is pulled and the striker opens the exhaust valve, the gaseous CO2 is vented off to propel the BB or pellet. The exhaust valve closes immediately, and CO2 gas is again boiled off until the vapor pressure reaches equilibrium with the remaining liquid. The evaporating CO2 has a refrigerant effect which noticeably cools the gun's chamber and barrel. This cooling effect can result in a slight, but steady, reduction of gas pressure if the gun is fired rapidly. Under normal conditions, however, the vapor pressure is constant and results in quite uniform velocities. The boiling-off period of CO2 gas, by the way, is virtually instantaneous, occurring faster than one can pull the trigger.

The speed and ease of shooting CO2 guns causes them to be fired more freely than other types of air guns, and this leads to the main objection: the expense of replacement gas cylinders. The number of shots per cylinder in most guns ranges from 30 to 80 or more. The last few shots from a nearly empty cylinder may have a noticeably lower velocity than normal. Some models feature a low-pressure release valve which automatically empties the cylinder when the CO2 pressure falls below practical shooting levels. 

Pellet and BB Caliber

Though there have been air guns that fire bullets as large as .60 caliber and as small as No. 6 shotgun shot (.110 inch), there has been, since the turn of the century, a trend toward standard sizes of air gun calibers. At present the four principal calibers are rather loosely known as .17, which includes BB's and .177 pellets; .20, which is the standard Sheridan caliber; .22, which includes a large array of pellet-firing pistols and rifles, and .25-caliber pellet and dart guns.  

Air Guns for Hunting

State regulations are often vague about the use of air-powered arms for hunting. Many states simply list the "legal arms" for hunting, and these commonly include rifle, shotgun, longbow and, in some cases, handgun. Air guns and crossbows are commonly omitted and are therefore technically illegal for hunting game. The objection to air guns and crossbows is that they are silent and ideal for poaching. In states that do not list air guns as legal for hunting, are they legal for shooting pests such as rats? Again, most states do not deal with the question in their regulations. Of course, air-powered arms are not powerful enough for big game, but if you are thinking of using one for small game hunting or pest control, it's best to ask your state conservation department whether it is legal to do so.   

This article was excerpted from Outdoor Life  magazine (copyright© 1980)  


Comparative Velocities of Spring Piston Air Guns

RIFLES:
 Anschutz 250  ( .177 caliber)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity (fps): 590

Beeman 75  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 650

BSA Meteor
 - Where made: Great Britain
 - Muzzle velocity ( .177 caliber): 650
 - Muzzle velocity ( .22 caliber): 500

BSA Mercury
 - Where made: Great Britain
 - Muzzle velocity ( .177): 700
 - Muzzle velocity ( .22) 550

Daisy Red Ryder  ( .117 BB)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 280

Daisy 499 Target  ( .117 BB)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 230

Daisy 95  ( .117 BB)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 325

El Gamo 68  ( .117)
 - Where made: Spain/Brazil
 - Muzzle velocity: 600

Feinwerkbau 300 Target  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 640

Feinwerkbau 124  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 800

Feinwerkbau 127  ( .22)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 680

Webley Hawk MK III
 - Where made: Great Britain
 - Muzzle velocity ( .177): 725
 - Muzzle velocity ( .22): 550

Webley Osprey
 - Where made: Great Britain
 - Muzzle velocity ( .177): 700
 - Muzzle velocity ( .22): 550

Weihrauch 35  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Caliber: .177
 - Muzzle velocity: 755

Wischo 55  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 760

PISTOLS
 Beeman 10  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 435

BSA Scorpion  ( .117)
 - Where made: Great Britain
 - Muzzle velocity: 500

Feinwerkbau 65  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 475

Webley MK II  ( .117)
 - Where made: Great Britain
 - Muzzle velocity: 435

Weihrauch  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Model: n/a
 - Muzzle velocity: 410

Wischo S-20  ( .117)
 - Where made: West Germany
 - Muzzle velocity: 450 


Comparative Pneumatic Velocities

RIFLES             
Benjamin 340 (.177 BB)
- Pump Strokes         2    4    6    8    10
- Velocity (fps)      415  533  612  667  704
Benjamin 347 (.177 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         2    4    6    8    10
- Velocity            382  510  588  652  694
Benjamin 342 (.22 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         2    4    6    8    10
- Velocity            344  468  534  587  626
Crossman 760 (.177 BB or Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         3      6      10
- Velocity (BB)       400    520    620
- Velocity (Pellet)   380    480    560
Crossman 766 (.177 BB or Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         3      6      10
- Velocity (BB)       450    587    710
- Velocity (Pellet)   428    567    637
Crossman 1377 (.177 BB or Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         3      6      10
- Velocity (BB)       350    470    535
- Velocity (Pellet)   335    460    495
Crossman 2200 (.22 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         3      6      10
- Velocity (BB)       375    495    600
Daisy 840 (.177 BB or Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         1   
- Velocity (BB)       320  
- Velocity (Pellet)   280
Daisy 880 (.177 BB or Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         2    4    6    8    10
- Velocity (BB)       410  540  625  675  710
- Velocity (Pellet)   375  500  575  625  650
Daisy 917 & 977 (.177 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         2    4    6    8    10
- Velocity            355  480  560  610  635
Daisy 922  (.22 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes         2    4    6    8    10
- Velocity            285  405  475  520  555
Sheridan Silver & Blue Streak (.20 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes    3    4    5    6    7    8
- Velocity       393  419  492  532  564  597
Walther LGR (.177 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     1   
- Velocity        580
Walther LP-3 (.177 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     1   
- Velocity        405

PISTOLS
Benjamin 130 (.177 BB)
- Pump Strokes     4    6    8    10
- Velocity        248  285  321  350
Benjamin 137 (.177 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     4    6    8    10
- Velocity        243  296  343  371
Benjamin 132 (.22 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     4    6    8    10
- Velocity        146  196  211  242
Crossman 1372 (.22 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     3      6      10
- Velocity        245    325    385
Daisy 717 (.177 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     1   
- Velocity        360
Daisy 722 (.22 Pellet)
- Pump Strokes     1   
- Velocity        290

Comparative Velocities of CO2 Guns

RIFLES
 Crossman 70  ( .117)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity (fps): 600 

Crossman 500  ( .117)
 - Where made: USA
 - Caliber: .177 (BB)
 - Muzzle velocity: 350

Sheridan F  ( .20)
 - Where made: USA
 - Caliber: .20
 - Muzzle velocity: 514

PISTOLS
 Crossman 38T  ( .22)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 356

Crossman  MK II  ( .117)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 425

Crossman 36  ( .177 BB)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 325

Crossman 44  ( .22)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 225

Daisy 1200  ( .117 BB)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 420

Hammerli Master  ( .117)
 - Where made: Swiss
 - Muzzle velocity: 390

Sheridan E  ( .20)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 375

Smith & Wesson 79G  ( .117)
 - Where made: USA
 - Muzzle velocity: 325 (low setting)   480 (hi setting)

All velocity figures are in feet per second (fps) 


Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next






Post a comment below.

 

N_3
3/28/2007 8:49:00 PM
Pre charged pneumatics utiising air reservoirs pressurised to 1000p.s.i.are now taking over as hunting air guns of choice in Europe. They are smooth in operation, as powerful as legal limits will allow (and with higher potential) suitable for scoped hunting and generally what you expect a good gun to feel like. They aren't as cheap as traditional spring/piston models but offer a good compromise between air and fire power.

Jeff_33
3/8/2007 3:47:56 AM
Interesting article but over and over you refer to airguns as firearms which they are not physically; most don't make any fire but the main point is that they don't ignite combustible material to produce the expanding gasses which propel the projectile down and out the barrel, nor legally, at least in these United States of America. The laws regarding airguns and firearms are different and do not commingle but as time progresses the all knowing government officials continue to try to alter these laws as to blur them into one general classification so to make easier the eventual, outright ban of any gun possessed by the general public. Kind of like what Stalin and Hitler did, you know. The overall ignorance of the people does nothing but promote the agenda of the “gun control” advocate and the eventual progress towards a dictatorship. So please, in the future, educate yourself first, then make clear to your readers the difference between the two. A good initial reference regarding this and many more airgun related topics is: http://www.beemans.net/ Regards, Jeffrey M Dobric








Subscribe Today - Pay Now & Save 66% Off the Cover Price

First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Lighten the Strain on the Earth and Your Budget

MOTHER EARTH NEWS is the guide to living — as one reader stated — “with little money and abundant happiness.” Every issue is an invaluable guide to leading a more sustainable life, covering ideas from fighting rising energy costs and protecting the environment to avoiding unnecessary spending on processed food. You’ll find tips for slashing heating bills; growing fresh, natural produce at home; and more. MOTHER EARTH NEWS helps you cut costs without sacrificing modern luxuries.

At MOTHER EARTH NEWS, we are dedicated to conserving our planet’s natural resources while helping you conserve your financial resources. That’s why we want you to save money and trees by subscribing through our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. By paying with a credit card, you save an additional $5 and get 6 issues of MOTHER EARTH NEWS for only $12.00 (USA only).

You may also use the Bill Me option and pay $17.00 for 6 issues.