MAX Update No. 43: Testing Aerodynamics With a Clear Car


| 4/6/2010 10:57:01 AM


Tags: MAX, 100 mpg, aerodynamics,

So, what did Wonder Woman's car (Update No. 37) have to teach us?

Some of it is a bit embarrassing, like slap my forehead and say “D’oh!” But at the time, it seemed like a clear car was a good idea. Tuft testing is a good idea — it's a bunch less expensive than wind tunnel testing and it gives immediate feedback — and I figured clear panels would let me observe the tufts while I drive. Pretty clever, eh?

Tuft testing lets the tester see what the air is doing on the surface of the object (MAX, in this case). Logically enough, smooth airflow is (usually — we'll talk about the exceptions in a different update) a good thing and turbulence is not, and tufts of yarn are excellent indicators of airflow quality (much like the traditional West Virginia Weather Rope: when it's wet it's raining, when it's swinging it's windy etc.).
 
But — big surprise — it turns out that a clear car does not improve tuft testing. Here's why:

• Observing while driving is not an optimal use of one's time. At the beginning of this year, Oregon passed a law forbidding the use of handheld cell phones when driving. I suspect tuft testing is equally distracting. Better to have somebody else take photos (or, even better, video) and do the analysis later, in the comfort of one’s own home, with a crackling fire and Bach in the bachground.

Aerodyanic Tuft Testing• If somebody else is doing the visual documentation, you don't need them in the car, so clear panels aren't going to help. A skilled photographer can pan the car as it goes by, a less sophisticated photographer can sit in the back seat of another car diving alongside. I had thought the wake of the camera car would be a problem, but we tried it with various cars at various distances. With a small camera car and a four lane road, when each car hugged the outside of our lanes, there was no noticeable aerodynamic interference. 

• For best results, the yarn should be a color that contrasts with the background color. Uh ... what contrasts with clear? I figured anything would, but found it depended entirely on what was in the car — my toolbox, my passenger, whatever. These bright orange tufts, which were so perfect against MAX's forest green paint job, are nearly invisible in this photo (which is why I photoshopped blue arrows in there). Adding red seats didn't help, either.




dairy goat

MOTHER EARTH NEWS FAIR

Aug. 5-6, 2017
Albany, Ore.

Discover a dazzling array of workshops and lectures designed to get you further down the path to independence and self-reliance.

LEARN MORE