Why You Should Abandon Antibacterial Soap
March/April 2007
Aubrey Vaughn
 |
MATTHEW T. STALLBAUMER
|
Antibacterial products have appeared in increasing quantities in
the last few years; but, contrary to common perception, using
antibacterial soaps, lotions, etc., isn't any better for you than
good old soap and water. In fact, it can actually be worse, for you
and the environment, for a few reasons:
RELATED ARTICLES
Haywood shares how she made soap on the homestead with a little help from the country agent...
Tips, recipes, and instructions on soapmaking, from preparing fat, recipes for all-purpose soap to ...
Modern agriculture is rushing us into an unintended but dangerous form of genetic engineering, incl...
Here are some tips on making soap and rendering fat and making lye....
For starters, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration conducted a
panel in 2005 that determined that using antimicrobial products
doesn't provide any more protection than regular soap. Using these
products can even be toxic.
Without clear evidence that antimicrobial products truly prevent
infection, the American Medical Association's official position
speaks against the practice of adding antimicrobials to the
products we use. They have even urged the FDA to avoid using these
chemicals until convincing evidence of their effectiveness is
available.
Triclocarban (TCC) is one of the most commonly used antimicrobials
and is also a pesticide. TCC leads to reproductive complications
(for mammals) as well as cancer, and, for human babies, can cause
blue-baby syndrome. When TCC residue washes down the drain, it's
immune to water treatments, meaning that most of the TCC resurfaces
in municipal sludge and is found in over half of U.S. streams.
Since municipal sludge is often used as crop fertilizer, TCC can
even potentially appear in our food supply.
As we continue to fill the environment with antimicrobials,
pathogens grow increasingly resistant to antibiotics. Some
antimicrobials actually encourage the natural production of
antibiotic-resistant bacteria, such as E. coli.
At present, there isn't any required tracking of TCC. However, we
do know that annually about 1 millions pounds of TCC are released
in the U.S. alone. In addition, roughly 1,500 antibacterial
products have been introduced to the market since 2000. One clear
message in this data is the need to consider the complete life
cycle of the chemicals we create and use.
For more information about antibacterial products and their
effects, check out Tabitha Alterman's article,
'Why You Don't Need Antibacterial Soap,' from
Mother
Earth News magazine.
This tip is adapted from
'Why You Don't Need Antibacterial Soap,' by Tabitha
Alterman.